Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
SortNewest |  Oldest |  Most Replied
  • Keeper League - I want Strasburg

    Dave by Dave . Jan 20, 2013 6:18 PM . Permalink

    What would it take to get him? Im in an 11 team, 5 player keeper league. Here are my keepers:

    Trout
    Cargo
    Longoria
    Posey
    Justin Upton

    I also have Madison Bumgarner and Chris sale.

    My target will likely keep: Strasburg, McCutch, Zobrist, Votto, and Gio.

    Would Upton be enough? Hoping to do this pre-draft.

    • Re: Keeper League - I want Strasburg

      Travis G by Travis G . Jan 24, 2013 6:54 PM . Permalink

      Zobrist leaves room for improvement, so yes a two for one may work. Upton and Bumgarner/ ...

      Zobrist leaves room for improvement, so yes a two for one may work. Upton and Bumgarner/ Posey/sale would possibly get the job done. I personally would try to keep Bumgarner and Stras to go with Trout, Cargo and Longo.

    • Re: Keeper League - I want Strasburg

      bob by bob . Jan 22, 2013 8:40 AM . Permalink

      not targeting trout as a keeper seems to me to be a losing concept. altho trying to meet ...

      not targeting trout as a keeper seems to me to be a losing concept. altho trying to meet your goals should be interesting, good luck, bob

    • Re: Keeper League - I want Strasburg

      Dylan by Dylan . Jan 22, 2013 7:17 AM . Permalink

      posey for Stras!

      posey
      for
      Stras!

    • Re: Keeper League - I want Strasburg

      Greenraven by Greenraven . Jan 22, 2013 5:56 AM . Permalink

      Trout is about it which means the price is too high. I don't trust the fragile arm of...

      Trout is about it which means the price is too high. I don't trust the fragile arm of any pitcher to trade away anyone of the above other than Upton depending on where he lands. And with only 5 keepers per team there will be plenty of good pitchers out there in the re-draft. Don't get hung up on some "ace" who already was injured once in his young career.

      Everyday position players are more important in your format of only 5 keepers I think. The fact that you will be dumping Sale and Bumgarner shows there will be plenty of really really good pitching dumped by your fellow owners as well.

    • Re: Keeper League - I want Strasburg

      BrewCrewDue by BrewCrewDue . Jan 20, 2013 7:27 PM . Permalink

      That's a big no. I think Strasburg is on the no trade level unless for a no trade lev...

      That's a big no. I think Strasburg is on the no trade level unless for a no trade level player itself.
      Trout,Posey but even Posey doesn't do it for me. You pair Sale with Longoria or Upton and I think that gets it done. Yeah that's the cost imo for Strasburg. He's top 3 pitcher potential which goes Kershaw,Verlander, him.
      Oh, and reading on his 5keepers are legit so sending 2 for 1 wont work as he'll be stuck dropping one anyway. Guess you suck it up and Offer Trout.