Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Back To Board
Search
Advanced Search  
  • Subject Message Body
  • Topics Only Topics And Messages
  • Any Date
  • Within the range:
Start a New Topic
View:  Summary |  Expanded
As:  Threaded |  Message List
Previous topic |  Next topic

  • Pick 6

    Justin by Justin . Jan 14, 2013 11:25 AM . Permalink
    Justin

    We keep 6, with the 4 highest drafted kept taking your first 4 rounds and the last 2 being the round they were drafted. 12 team H2H scoring of R,HR,RBI,SB,AVG,OBP/SV,K,HLD,ERA,WHIP,QS

    Which 6 would you take? Thoughts and opinions appreciated.

    Shock an Awe
    1. Robinson Canó
    2. Evan Longoria
    3. Elvis Andrus
    4. Eric Hosmer
    5. Matt Cain
    6. Michael Bourn
    9. Tommy Hanson
    10. Billy Butler
    13. Tim Hudson
    15. Rafael Betancourt
    16. Johnny Cueto
    22. Mike Minor
    (everyone after Minor is a player picked up during the season and will be valued as a Round 28 player)
    Luis Cruz
    Jonathan Lucroy
    Juan Pierre
    Josh Reddick
    Carlos Ruiz
    Alex Rios
    Alfonso Soriano
    Bronson Arroyo
    Zach Britton
    Ross Detwiller
    Jeremy Guthrie
    Casey Jannssen
    Kyle Kendrick
    Edward Mujica
    Kris Medlen

    Right now i am leaning towards
    1. Cano
    2. Longoria
    3. Cain
    4. Butler
    16. Cueto
    28. Medlen

    • bob

      Re: Pick 6

      bob by bob . Jan 14, 2013 11:41 AM . Permalink

      cano,longoria, andrus,butler,bourn,cain. medlin is a possibility as well.

      cano,longoria, andrus,butler,bourn,cain. medlin is a possibility as well.

    • Max

      Re: Pick 6

      Max by Max . Jan 14, 2013 9:41 PM . Permalink

      Cano, Longo, Cain, Andrus/Butler, Cueto, Medlen. Id take Andrus with SS shallow and 1B dee...

      Cano, Longo, Cain, Andrus/Butler, Cueto, Medlen. Id take Andrus with SS shallow and 1B deep. But id try to trade Andrus and a guy like Rios/Reddick, good value for maybe Tulo if possible, or a OF bat. Or try Butler and a Reddick/Rios/Medlen for a top 1B bat and keep Andrus and new 1B.

    • Durf

      Re: Pick 6

      Durf by Durf . Jan 14, 2013 5:03 PM . Permalink

      Can you pick 2 players from the 28 group? I'd keep Cano, Longoria, and Andrus, and ei...

      Can you pick 2 players from the 28 group? I'd keep Cano, Longoria, and Andrus, and either Cain/Butler. I'd keep Medlen at 28 for sure, and add Rios/Reddick at 27 if possible.

      Or keep Cain as 4th pick and keep Butler as 10th with Medlen 28.

    • Danny

      Re: Pick 6

      Danny by Danny . Jan 14, 2013 3:40 PM . Permalink

      That's what I would do,also. I would pass on Bourn this year. Most players don't...

      That's what I would do,also. I would pass on Bourn this year. Most players don't produce in their first years with a new team.

    • BrewCrewDue

      Re: Pick 6

      BrewCrewDue by BrewCrewDue . Jan 14, 2013 9:52 PM . Permalink

      Going a little different here. Cano,Longoria,Cain,Butler,Medlin,Lucroy. Medlin/Lucroy ar...

      Going a little different here.
      Cano,Longoria,Cain,Butler,Medlin,Lucroy. Medlin/Lucroy are Not 28rd players and will go much earlier. Since you don't lose any picks but 27/28 you can draft with the higher picks accordingly to their value of draft position. Well, maybe I go the way you go, I thought Cueto was a higher round pick. LOL So what you are doing is what I'd do. That or keep Lucroy vs. Medlen.