Votto, Craig, Upton and Felix. Trumbo is to much of a risk. Jones did great but that's just one year (show me 2 and we'll talk). Lawrie has upside but showed little, you can get him back. Castro did well, but there are other better options to be had if everyone only keeps 4 players. If you didn't list Allen Craig I would have said keep Castro. I really like Craig and expect big things from him.