shane, compare Craigs numbers to Holliday. Now consider the fact he did that in 140 less at bats because he missed the beginning of the season. Like I said above I like Holliday, I even own him, but if I had to pick between the two I'm going with Craig.
And you can bring up injuries to Craig if you want, but I can bring up the same amount of injuries with Holliday. You can't go wrong with either pick, it's a matter of preferences I guess, but I go with Craig. Next year you'll thank me.