Don't believe Haren is done. He had an off injury year, but he is far from done. I like Bauer but just like every other rookie pitcher, he hasn't proved anything on the ML level yet. He's a risk, but he has a lot of upside. If it's your 10th spot and the rest of your team is full of established players and not a lot of rookies that you can win with now, keep Haren or Austin Jackson. If you are in a rebuilding mode and have 3 or 4 young/rookie players that need a year or two to mature, keep Bauer (or Jackson since he's not that old either).