Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Start a New Topic

View: Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Message List

Previous topic | Next topic

Holliday or Craig?

Dewey by Dewey . Sep 24, 2012 10:34 AM . Permalink

I'm trying to decide who I want as my 5th keeper. As a STL cards fan, and a HUGE Matt Holliday fan, I need outside help. I'm too biased.

I'm deciding between Matt Holliday (OF) and Allen Craig (1B,2B,OF). Craig has put up some nice numbers, and has more eligibility.

My other keepers are:
Adrain Gonzalez (1B, OF)
Matt Kemp (OF)
Andrew McCutchen (OF)
Justin Verlander (SP)

Thanks for all your help!
- 0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
- Reply
- Report Abuse
- Re: Holliday or Craig?
  
  Sluggo by Sluggo . Sep 24, 2012 11:58 AM . Permalink
  
  I think Craigs eligibilty is really why you are even considering him over Holliday. Even t...
  
  I think Craigs eligibilty is really why you are even considering him over Holliday. Even though the "smart guys" are saying that 2B is going to be really thin next year, I'd still stick with Holliday.
  1 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
  - View Replies
  - Re: Re: Holliday or Craig?
    
    Dewey by Dewey . Sep 24, 2012 12:29 PM . Permalink
    
    Thank you!
    
    Thank you!
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
- Re: Holliday or Craig?
  
  Shane by Shane . Sep 24, 2012 2:47 PM . Permalink
  
  Take Holliday. Craig won't even be 2B eligible next year.
  
  Take Holliday. Craig won't even be 2B eligible next year.
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- Re: Holliday or Craig?
  
  Chustri by Chustri . Sep 24, 2012 2:52 PM . Permalink
  
  keep both and let go Adrian
  
  keep both and let go Adrian
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse

Yahoo! Sports

Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest.

Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Yahoo! Sports

Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Re: Holliday or Craig?

Yahoo! Sports

Also On Yahoo!

Trending Now