• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the posts
  • Chad Chad Sep 22, 2012 3:02 PM Flag

    Medlen or Sale

    thats a pretty tough choice. seemingly, both have high ceilings and both are relatively unproven. I prefer pitchers in the NL vs the AL but thats just me. Flip a coin, I don't think you will go wrong either way. Also I wouldn't expect Medlen to keep up this streak of awesomeness.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • If only I could keep them both. I have more keepers than I know what to do with and I can only keep 3 (Craig, Cespedes, Ian Desmond, Rizzo, Sale, Medlen, Molina). I'm leaning towards Sale right now just because he has more name-value and I think Medlen will be drafted way later so I can get him for cheap, but damn he's making it tough on me.

      • 2 Replies to Dr. Steve Brule
      • If it were me with those choices, I wouldn't keep Cespedes or Rizzo (OF and 1B are pretty deep positions) or Craig, as much as I love him. He's been injured a lot already in his relatively short career and probably more importantly, he loses 2B eligibility next year, leaving him only 1B and OF. Again, those are pretty deep positions. Molina's a tough one. Great player at a shallow position, but I'm not sure if the Cards would sit him more often than he usually does since they've invested a lot of money on him. The Twins have done that with Mauer, and he's only a year younger than Molina. The Twins also have the advantage of the DH and 1B to play Mauer more often, which the Cards don't have. I could see Molina being a 3/4 of a season player, which is still about 120 games, but if I'm keeping a player, I would want to see more guaranteed playing time.

        If I had your choices, I would keep Desmond, Sale, and basically flip a coin on Medlen and Molina, with an edge towards Molina.

      • Don't keep Cespedes or Rizzo, they are pretty easy to replace with the positions they play on, so there, now you can keep Medlen and Sale,

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football