We keep 3. My options are Posey, Freeman, Pedroia, Trout, Holliday, Harper, Votto, Tulo, Lee, Lincecum, Bumgarner, J. Zimmerman.
posey votto and trout
Trout, Votto, Tulo. Answer my "Who to Drop For A-Rod" thread please.
I would say posey, trout, tulo. First base is always to deep and catcher that hits for avg and power is rare. If you keep a pitcher I would say Bumgarner.