I agree. If Young becomes your second baseman I probably would decline. How bad do you need SP help? I'm looking to trade for Weaver too, help me out?
I give Wright, J Upton, and Sale
I get Headley, Maurer, and Weaver
I need a catcher and can afford to lose Upton in the OF, plus not seeing much of a difference between Headley and Wright since all star break.
Depends on your rotation and 2B depth I guess. This ones tough. Personally, I wouldn't trade first round IF talent for a SP, unless I had an above average back-up for Cano (which Young is not). But Weaver is a top-10 SP and youre receiving a nice upgrade at RP. Fair offer, but I'd lean towards rejecting.