player rankings tell you what they have ALREADY done. Not what they will do. You have a lot of players having career years with no history of having done it before and track records to prove they can continue to do it, hence players like encarnacion, cabrera, capuano. etc. And I would bet you anything that players like reddick, miley, capuano, diamond, etc dont continue to play the way they have in the second half. but everyone has different opinions and i'm happy you're happy with your team.