Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Start a New Topic

View: Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Message List

Stanton trade help

John by John . May 10, 2012 2:24 AM . Permalink

I give
Cuddyer
Peavy

I get
Stanton

How is this trade? good or bad?
Looks like stanton is heating up and I just dont like cuddyer.
12 teams 5x5 roto leageu

my team
c - Weiters
1b - Fielder
2b - Uggla
3b - Zimmerman
ss - Tulo
of - BJ Upton
of - Stubbs
of - Cuddyer
utl - LaHair
bn - Hardy
bn - Moustakas
bn - Cespedes

sp - Kershaw
sp - Halladay
rp - Henry Rodriguez
rp - Myers
p - Wainwright
p - Peavy
p - Fister
bn - Tim Hudson
bn - Daniel Hudson
DL - Farnsworth
- 0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
- Reply
- Report Abuse
- Re: Stanton trade help
  
  Chris by Chris . May 10, 2012 2:31 AM . Permalink
  
  I wouldn't do it for Peavy alone. I think you are getting screwed in this trade, and b...
  
  I wouldn't do it for Peavy alone. I think you are getting screwed in this trade, and besides Cuddyer plays multiple positions which helps you
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
  - View Replies
  - Re: Stanton trade help
    
    John by John . May 10, 2012 2:42 AM . Permalink
    
    I know peavy is pitching really good, but I just think he cant keep that up whole season. ...
    
    I know peavy is pitching really good, but I just think he cant keep that up whole season. And I really rate Stanton, potential of 40 HR ?
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
- Re: Stanton trade help
  
  team j by team j . May 10, 2012 2:50 AM . Permalink
  
  i say halladay and cuddyer
  
  i say halladay and cuddyer
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
  - View Replies
  - Re: Stanton trade help
    
    Chris by Chris . May 10, 2012 2:53 AM . Permalink
    
    No stanton isnt worth Halladay.. If I were you, you need to trust that Stanton will be goo...
    
    No stanton isnt worth Halladay.. If I were you, you need to trust that Stanton will be good all season
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
- Re: Stanton trade help
  
  Chris by Chris . May 10, 2012 2:48 AM . Permalink
  
  maybe... but i would not do both just for stanton, he is of value but not for the value of...
  
  maybe... but i would not do both just for stanton, he is of value but not for the value of a 2:1 ratio.. maybe see what else you can get out of that trade..
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- Re: Stanton trade help
  
  Aaron by Aaron . May 10, 2012 2:58 AM . Permalink
  
  Bad. Do Uggla and Tim Hudson for Stanton if you really want Stanton.
  
  Bad. Do Uggla and Tim Hudson for Stanton if you really want Stanton.
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
  - View Replies
  - Re: Stanton trade help
    
    team j by team j . May 10, 2012 3:10 AM . Permalink
    
    but for stanton i say its worth the reward
    
    but for stanton i say its worth the reward
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
  - Re: Stanton trade help
    
    team j by team j . May 10, 2012 3:10 AM . Permalink
    
    you can do uggla if you have a quality back up 2basemen unless you will use cuddyer at 2
    
    you can do uggla if you have a quality back up 2basemen unless you will use cuddyer at 2
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
- Re: Stanton trade help
  
  team j by team j . May 10, 2012 2:56 AM . Permalink
  
  how about peavy and upton
  
  how about peavy and upton
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- View More Messages

Yahoo! Sports

Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest.

Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Yahoo! Sports

Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Re: Stanton trade help

Yahoo! Sports

Also On Yahoo!

Trending Now