• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • John John May 2, 2012 6:07 AM Flag

    Halladay trade HELP plz

    I give
    David Price
    Aramis Ramirez

    I get
    Roy Halladay
    Michael Cuddyer

    Recently I gave away Jason Werth to get Aramis because Zimmerman was placed on DL, and I also picked up
    Mike Moustakas from FA so I have plenty of 3B.

    Do I accept this trade?
    its 12 teams 5x5 roto league.

    my team is

    C - Weiters
    1B- Fielder
    2B- Uggla
    3B- Aramis
    SS- Tulo
    OF- BJ Upton
    OF- Cespedes
    OF- Stubbs
    UTL- Reimold
    BN- Moustakas
    DL- Zimmerman

    SP- Kershaw
    SP- Price
    RP- Henry Rodriguez
    RP- Myers
    P - Peavy
    P - Wainwright
    P - Tim Hudson
    BN- Daniel Hudson
    BN- Fister
    BN- Reed
    DL- Farnsworth

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Unless I'm missing something I would say yes. Aramis should put up beter overall number than Cuddyer, but not by too much. Plus Cuddyer gives you multiple positions. Halladay over Price is enough in my book to make up that drop in offense.

 

Expert Fantasy Advice