I'd be giving Justin Upton and David Freese I'll be getting Mark Teixiera and David Wright
My lineup right now consists of: C - Miguel Montero 1B - Eric Hosmer 2B - Dustin Ackley 3B - Hanley Ramirez, David Freese SS - Troy Tulowitzki OF - Justin Upton, Jordan Schafer, Nolan Reimold, Desmond Jennings, and J.D. Martinez Util - David Ortiz
The scoring is head to head with the standard ten categories.
I like Upton's upside if he's healthy but Mark is almost a guarantee of 30+ HR's with around 100 RBI's. Plus I think long term David Wright will outperform Freese by a long shot.
I love J. Upton but I like this trade for you so I would do it, only thing that would be tough is playing everyone, I only see 1 utility spot and papi is there, and o.f. would be much weaker, I dont know now,..tough call, sorry for flip flop