• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Eman Eman Apr 23, 2012 4:35 PM Flag

    Trade for Bourn

    I'm in need of SB. I want to acquire Michael Bourn. Which of these 2 pitchers should I give up in order to get him?

    Matt Garza

    or

    Brandon Beachy


    Thanks.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • i wouldnt give up Beachy for Bourne. drop your worst pitcher and adda basestealer. Bourne wont hit 300 again, hes a 1 or 2 category player

    • I think most FA managers will recognize Beachy as the more valuable pitcher, his .047 ERA and penchant for break-out potential by most pundits will have him held in high regard. It is with that said Matt Garza is the better player. Consistancy is the gold seal of success in Fantasy Baseball and Garza has averaged 190+ IP and over 8/K9 the last four seasons.

      That covers the relative value of the two pitchers you are offering.

      As for trading for Bourn good luck. Two problems exist: a) he has been incredibly hot lately, and has got his avg up to an astoundng .338. b) most players who drafted him did so with the expectation he would buoy their SB standing alone - something he probably will do. Medocre pitching is so plentiful in the standard league format, it would be fairly impossible to get him for a pitcher outside of the top 15.

      Perhaps, and only if, your competitor has zero pitching and has both Emilo and Dee Gordon could you get Bourn for Garza or Beachy.

      You will be better off looking to the waiver wire for cheap steals - De Aza, Scheter, etc.

    • I would rather keep Beachy than Garza.

      Dont know if it helps at all but I just GAVE Bourn and Beckett and got Hamels. 10 team H2H.

 

Expert Fantasy Advice