Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
10-team roto league, we keep 10 each year.
Cats are: R H HR RBI SB K AVG OPS
W L SV HLD ERA K/9 WHIP QS
Other positions/needs aside, who wins?
A: Kershaw, Weaver, Konerko
B: Votto, Lincecum, Youkilis
Please evalute both 2012-13 and next two-or-so seasons moving forward. Thanks in advance!
I'd lean towards option B. I'd be very surprised if Youk's batting average doesn't climb back to the near-.300, and it'll be near impossible for Lincecum to post another losing record with the WHIP/ERA/K figures he keeps posting. Joey Votto is just a monster, no need to explain that.
I love Konerko, and I think he's undervalued, but if you're looking toward the future, you'd expect a 35 y/o to decline a bit. There isn't a ton negative about Kershaw or Weaver, but I'd prefer Lincecum to them, as he's had more season at an elite level.
Check out my thread as well, I'm desperate for some advice: http://messages.fantasysports.yahoo.com/Fantasy_Sports/Baseball/threadview?m=tm&bn=fan-baseball-drafttalk&tid=213864327&mid=213864327&tof=15&frt=2