Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
I am offered the next thing..
(10 keepers league - 12 teams)
J,Montero (other) for D.Jennings (me) and my 4th round pick (41st after keepers) for his 5th round pick (55th)
Is this a good proposal..
AND what i cannot see why this kid ;) also tries to trade my Matt Cain for Cole Hamels.. i do not see it, what is the catch behind this one
Can anybody help me..
That is a hard one Cain vs. Hamels. They are almost equal in all that they do. Cain is a year younger than Cole. Cole may not have the same lineup this year with Howard getting hurt (and may not be ready until mid-May at the earliest). Cain could be helped with a better lineup (with Posey and Sanchez returning, Aubrey Huff returning to his 2010 form and Brandon Belt ready to show what he can do). I would take Cain.
- 1 Reply to grady
Home ballpark counts for something, but still think Hamels is the better Keeper here.
To answer the question of why he would want the trade... it really doesn't matter, so long as you the offer looks good in your valuation of each player. Hell, maybe he's just a Giants fan.
i'd rather keep jennings. i'd also think jennings is better than montero, so why would you give up the better draft pick too?
cain for hammels might just be his personal preference. i'd take that as i have hammels easily over cain.
please answer my j upton/fielder/mccutch for cano/bautista post.