I'd go with Hanley. Ellsbury is a great player and had a career year but I'm not sure I would bank on last years stats being who Ellsbury is and will be from here on out. Still very good but Hanely has been the first or second guy off any board/any format for years. Too talented so I think he'll bounce back just fine. Hanley will probably hold on to the SS elig for another year as well. I usually base trades off of the body of work and not just one great or poor year....Good luck!