Yeah, I'll admit I did miss exactly what Weaver has done this year. But I would still take Roy over Weaver anyday of the month. 1+ year for Weaver is a much smaller sample size than what Roy has showed me over the last decade or so.
Also, I think some people are giving too much credit to Cruz. You do realize Stubbs is a top 35-40 player right now while Nelson is closer to 65-70??