• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Mike Mike Jun 17, 2011 6:28 PM Flag

    Proposed offer: Accept or Reject?

    I get Vogelsong
    I give Gardner and Brantley

    My OF = Holiday, Bourn, Boesch, Stanton
    My SP- CC, Gallardo, Kuroda, Karstens, Norris

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Take the trade.

      Vogelsong is having a great year... wouldn't keep him in a keeper League, but have him on a few rosters.

      The key here is you are improving your team. You're not giving away a superstar, you open up a position and can afford to give up the offense.

      I don't know what else you need...

    • It's definitely not a bad trade, but I wouldn't accept. Vogelsong is a 33-ish year old pitcher who is largely unproven, but having a good year. You're giving up a guy in Gardner that has great speed and is in a great lineup - 100R potential and 25SB; He was awful to start the season, but look at him for the last 30 days - rock solid and back to normal. That's a tough guy to find and he's young, so he is likely on the upside, whereas Vogelsong to me is more like a Karstens type, low K, low potential, overachieving.

    • Yeah you could use the pitching. Both of those guys have been on and off the wire in my league.

      I think youre good


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football