Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
Good Trade to make or sit tight?
12 Team - H2H - 6x6 - Keeper (Keep 4 Players)
I give: Phillips, McCutchen
I get: Cano, Michael Morse
My Current Team:
C - Santana
1B - Votto
2B - Phillips
3B - Sandoval
SS - Alexei
OF - Braun
OF - Holliday
OF - McCutchen
OF - Victorino
UTIL - Hosmer
BN - Swisher, Brantley, Moustakas
SP - Weaver, Cahill, J.Garcia, E.Santana, Jurrjens, Dempster, Scherzer
RP - Marmol, Santos, Kimbrel, Gregg
DL - Colon
- 1 Reply to TK from LA
in a keeper u want the best players at the shallowist positions.
2b is shallow and an OF can be re built every year. more to choose from etc etc. as well as sp being so deep, only keeping 4 there will plenty of SP at next years draft. plus u still have braun and holliday.
Having braun,votto,cano, and holliday, isnt that bad, plus u could always trade holliday For a stud 3b to keep aka zimm/longoria or for tulo or hanley.
- 1 Reply to Scott
In a keeper league where you keep 4 player, this is definitely not too much to give up for the best player at the shallowest position. He is again going to be 25 HR and 100RBI this year and he hasn't had the BA he has had the past two years. If the guys wants this deal then do it. As a Cano owner, I probably still wouldn't take this deal.
- 1 Reply to The Truth
I am as well....I am not sure what moves to make to be honest. I have a lot of options which is a good thing...just makes it tough. I almost have to establish who my keepers are and go from there.
Maybe I should offer Phillips/Holliday for Cano and Someone either an Ace or something.
Food for thought...at some point this year you NEED to trade Hosmer and Moustakas to someone looking for a young keepers. if you make this trade your 4 keepers are Votto, Cano, Bruan and Holliday...Hosmer and Moustakas arent going to REALLY produce this year the numbers you could get in trading for someone who can...just IMO
- 1 Reply to gmenfan65
No I absolutely agree....I am trying to trade them, just not easy. This trade actually started Hoser and Phillips for Cano but he wasnt interested. I play in a league where people only want big name guys...its rediculous and every trade offer involves big name guys.
I am definitely trying....I have also considered trading Sandoval and getting something I can use and then just have Moustakas as my 3B this year.
I am also considering trading Holliday...but need to figure out what to get for him....Do I go after an Ace? or do I throw him in the Cano deal instead of McCutchen and see what I can do.
- View More Messages