Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
Give - J Weaver, T Hunter, C Marmol
Get - M Holliday, B Anderson, and C Kimbrel
Does this trade benefit me or should I try to get an upgrade at 2B? I am in a Standard Roto Scoring league.
Currently, I have a deal to trade Y Escobar for A Ramirez.
C - C Santana
1B - A Dunn
2B - D Barney
3B - J Bautista
SS - Y Escobar
OF - R Braun, T Hunter, J Ellsbury
UTIL - M Joyce and Markakis
BN - Fuld and J Bay
DL - P Sandoval
SP - Lincecum and Jerad Weaver
RP - Marmol and S Santos
P - Rodney, Rauch, R Nolasco, R Romero, J Contraras, K Lohse
C - G Soto
1B - A Pujols
2B - R Weeks
3B - P Alvarez
SS - J Rollins
OF - M Holliday, J Werth, M Kemp
UTIL - C Young and B Butler
BN - M Izturis, G Sizemore, D Fowler, and A Cabrera
E Volquez, J De La Rosa, C Kimbrel, L Nunez, M Adams, G Gonzalez, B Anderson, D Hudson, and G Floyd
If you can get Holliday, do it. You get a great SP and RP back, and get a serious upgrade at OF, especially if power matters in your league.
(Thanks for your comment on Hart/Hellickson. I like Hellickson a lot, but think he is a year or two away from dependability)
As much as I like Weaver, the key here is getting Holliday. Take the deal and hope that Anderson stays healthy. Kimbrel will probably get you more saves than Marmol because of their teams. Take the trade.