Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
  • Which 2 of Haren, Liriano, Rollins?

    rising by rising . Feb 15, 2011 11:06 AM . Permalink

    I can keep 2 of those 3 players, based on our keeper rules, for this season. Which 2?

    I know pitchers are deep and SS is thin, but Rollins is sketchy and Haren is due to bounce back, I'd think.

    So?

    • Re: Which 2 of Haren, Liriano, Rollins?

      Durf by Durf . Feb 16, 2011 8:27 AM . Permalink

      Thanks for responding! I kind of like it b/c it means there is still a lot of good player...

      Thanks for responding! I kind of like it b/c it means there is still a lot of good players left in the next year's draft and doesn't diminish the excitement.

      It also encourages to pick up players that come out of nowhere midway through the season b/c they'll have a lower rank.

      I'm going to add this option as a vote for our league...

    • Re: Which 2 of Haren, Liriano, Rollins?

      rising by rising . Feb 15, 2011 8:39 PM . Permalink

      We're going into our third year, and I like it, yeah. I've never heard of any othe...

      We're going into our third year, and I like it, yeah. I've never heard of any other league doing it this way though.

      I like it because it creates parity - this definitely isn't good if you want to build a powerhouse and keep the whole team together... I'm forced to lose Holliday, Beltre, Oswalt, etc in the top 25

      The nice thing is that if a good player gets hurt, you can probably keep them because they finish ranked lower. So if they hurt you this year, you can keep them easier. On the other hand, overperforming players probably need to be dropped, because there's no room to keep them. We end up dealing players we can't keep for picks, etc. I was in 1st place last year with enough of a lead that I felt safe dealing CarGo for a bunch of players and a lottery pick, since I couldn't keep him.

    • Re: Which 2 of Haren, Liriano, Rollins?

      Brooklyn Streetz by Brooklyn Streetz . Feb 15, 2011 4:41 PM . Permalink

      Let Rollins go and draft someone like Stephen Drew ... Rollins is on steady decline.

      Let Rollins go and draft someone like Stephen Drew ... Rollins is on steady decline.

    • Re: Which 2 of Haren, Liriano, Rollins?

      JFat by JFat . Feb 15, 2011 11:48 AM . Permalink

      I like Haren/Liriano

      I like Haren/Liriano