Ryan Braun inconsistent? since he came into the majors he averages 95+ runs, 25+ Hr's,100+ RBI's,300avg, and dozen SB. I don't see the inconsistentancy. And he plays almost every game without missing any significant time on the DL. He was hurt this year by Fielder off year. His first half numbers are almost identical to his second half numbers besides the fact he hits for a higher average after the AS break.
As for everyone jumping on Carl Crawford, you have to remember that he is a FA and he can end up anywhere. He just had a career year in Hrs, Rbi's, runs, & 2nd highest year in Avg. he isn't going to duplicate that power every year especially if he leaves Tropicana field which deepest part of the OF is only 404 and 370 in the power alley.
I'd go with Cabrera who is a solid 1st baseman that hits for power and high avg. then Braun over Crawford (really are those extra SB worth it over Braun's power #'s) then Mr. Cy Young Felix.