Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

Cliff Lee. Is it even a question? Garcia's a rookie whose xFIP is 1.5 higher than hi...

Cliff Lee. Is it even a question? Garcia's a rookie whose xFIP is 1.5 higher than his ERA, and Cliff Lee is one of the top five pitchers in baseball...

Cliff Lee. Garcia is good, but has no track record, etc.

Cliff Lee. Garcia is good, but has no track record, etc.

sophomore slump coming from Garcia...and I'm an STL fan

sophomore slump coming from Garcia...and I'm an STL fan

I would go with Cliff since he isn't old and will surely sign with a contender and I d...

I would go with Cliff since he isn't old and will surely sign with a contender and I doubt Garcia will ever be better than he is now though he could be as good but Cliff is safer and you prob won't regret keeping him for a few more years.

Lee and its not even close

Lee and its not even close