I'd take Jones, he had a solid year last year before he got hurt. And although he hasn't performed to par this season, he's also been moved around quite a bit in that YOUNG lineup due to lead-off ineptitude of the rest of the squad. Jones is not suited for a lead-off, a role he was forced into early in the season. Grady Sizemore gets hurt every year, and if he doesn't? How many years will he hurt you when he does.