• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Jasper Jasper May 18, 2010 10:53 AM Flag

    Monster deal..

    Hey guys, I was just offered the following:

    Kershaw
    Rasmus
    Sandoval

    for

    Niemann
    Zimmerman

    What do you think?

    Niemann has a better ERA and WHIP but is in a risky division, Kershaw has more K's and better career numbers (though he's struggling this year), Rasmus would help me fill a minor void in OF, Sandoval has monster career stats, but is he better (on this Giants team) then Zim right now?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I just counter offered this

      I get:
      Josh Johnson
      Sandoval
      Rasmus

      He gets:
      Niemann
      Zimmerman
      Garrett Jones.

      I think this is an equal deal (Johnson and Niemann equal out.. Johnson more K's, Nieman better ERA etc), Zim > Sandoval so far, Rasmus > Jones. Agreed?

    • To make things clear: I'm giving up Niemann/Zim.

      Also, I'm thinking about asking for Josh Johnson in return, in stead of Kershaw. He's closer to Niemann's numbers. Maybe I should tweak it here and there and throw in someone else, make it 3-for-3?