Kelly Johnson is a sell high player who will not keep it up. Justin Upton will continue his disappointing season. Andrew McCutchen is the only bright-spot on an otherwise not very good team (He'll get you some stolen bases and some ocassional runs, but I don't see him getting you much more than that.) The other side has Guillen (I'm assuming Jose) who is surprising right now. Jeter who plays for a powerhouse team and is a perenial stat producer (I'm not a Yankees fan), and Victorino who like Jeter, bats at the top of a really good team. I say the second group is a better team in a heart beat.