Based on prior stats they both suck. I have Rodney on my team waiting for Fuentes to screw up. He's been fine so far but history says he's going to take his lumps. Having the Angels closer is a great thing but there is no certainty that Rodney will ever get that job. Linstrom has always sucked but at least he is a closer. Ok - my answer is this. I'd rather have Rodney today and hold him for the next two weeks to see if he gets the gig. I'd rather have Lindstrom if I couldn't wait. Lousy answer. sorry
Rather have Lindstrom since he's actually a closer. Only exception is if your league counts holds. Then Rodney is better cause he can atleast get you holds until Mike S. wakes up and realizes Fuentes sucks.