I'd take the side who's getting Morneau and Ramirez. Morneau will have 30-40 HRs and Ramirez will hit 20+ himself. In terms of RBIs, Morneau + Ramirez > Pujols.
I'd take it in a heartbeat. Pujols is good, but he's only 1 man, and god forbid if he goes down with an injury. With a revamped MIN offense, Morneau will have a ton of opportunities to get 100+ RBIs and he'll still have a respectable BA in the .280s.