Butler, Pedroia, Aramis RamirezforDunn, Reynolds, Aaron HillIs this a fair trade??
It's a fair trade.Pedroia slight edge over Hill, but Hill more power.Butler very slight edge over Dunn because of BA.Reynolds definite edge over Aram.I'd take the Dunn side, but barely.
If you need power, take the Dunn/Reynolds/Hill side for sure
thanks, I'm the one who needs power. Should I take off some players?
If you got guys who can make up the average do it.
Not sure, Reynolds & Hill both had amazing years but it will be very hard for both to duplicate that success.
Butler Pedroia and Aramis are far better overall. If you get more for power then grab the other 3.