• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • jh jh Mar 29, 2010 3:45 PM Flag

    shortstop discussion

    lets start a debate on who you would rather have at ss to help me make my decision......i currently have jeter but would you want him over rollins and reyes....who will have a better year???

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • i got jeter right after rollins in the 3rd round and reyes went off the board shortly after....should i trade jeter for either rollins or reyes in some kind of deal???

      heres my team

      posada, montero(soto is FA)
      morneau, ortiz
      utley
      jeter
      aramis ramirez
      crawford
      c. lee
      t. hunter
      n. mclouth
      n. cruz

      f.hernandez
      j. santana
      j. beckett
      j. shields
      t. lilly
      c. bucholz
      strasburg
      krod
      hoffman

    • Good question.

      I'm always partial to Reyes, but the #'s Jeter put up last year in the new park are hard to argue with. I personally think that Rollins is on the decline. I guess it all comes down to value.

      Right now, Rollins is going about 31, and Jeter about 34, so if either or both are available in round 3, I'd take them (I'd lean towards Jeter), but if you think he'll still be there, I'd rather have Reyes in the 4th.

      For more advice, check out my daily blog: fantasysteve.blogspot.com -- Good info and good links.

    • I'm liking Rollins a lot this year. Solid second half last year, he's looked solid in the spring and he's looking to take a bunch of bases. I'd bet he beats Jeter in every cat other than average this year.

      I love Reyes but I'm thinking it might take a few months for him to get back to his previous form, he's been on the shelf for a while.