Id go kendrick, Theriot walks a lot! Doesnt really help you unless you have obp in your league. Theriot comes up to the plate looking for a walk, and defends the 3rd strike by trying to slap the ball. Whereas Kendrick comes up swinging. Honestly Theriot has a better approach, but Kendrick's hitting ability is far superior. Kendrick might even get you a couple home runs. Id go with Kendrick.