Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

bump....

heres his team:

C johjima
1B Jackson
2B Upton
3B Escobar
OF Holliday
OF Kemp
OF Ibanez
Util Uggla
BN Loney
BN Theriot
BN Damon
BN Fukudome

SP - Webb, E. Santana, Mussina, King Felix, Lester, C. Young
RP - Jenks, Nathan

You tell me what would be a fair offer: lowell and matsui for yunel and someone else. i could also use a pitcher

asking for holliday is ridiculous

wat you countered was a joke no way i would laugh if i was countered that, it terribly lopsided. the original trade was fair. what you sent was just ridiculus

Asking for Holliday is way too much. He's leaps and bounds ahead of all four of the other guys.

Make the trade he originally proposed now.

Deal lowell now he won't repeat last years numbers.

maybe holliday is too much. but this is the third time this guy has offered me a trade for matsui and i am just seeing how far he will go to get him. I have a stacked team already with ortiz, utley, soto, mclouth, upton, and guillen, cant hurt to try and see. what about kemp and yunel? any better?

Nobody in their right mind will send you Matt Holliday (let alone Y. Escobar too) for Mike Lowell and Matzui. The first offer was pretty fair. I wouldn't call Fukudome unproven...the guy was an all-star every year in Japan. Escobar isn't really unproven either since he hit above .300 last year for Atlanta too. And he's eligable to play 3 positions....but nobody is going to give you a top 15 hitter for two guys that may or may not be top 80 hitters.

bump ...