Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
I have been offered Alex Rios/Edgar Renteria/Joe Nathan/Brett Myers for Magglio Ordonez/Derek Jeter/Eric Gagne/Javier Vazquez. I feel like it is an OK deal but the other guy gets Jeter and Vazquez who I feel are better than Renteria/Myers. My closers would be Papelbon, Putz, Nathan, and Lidge if I did this deal, which I like a lot. My hitting is Russell Martin, Carlos Pena, Chase Utley, Ryan Braun, Berkman, Michael Young, Aaron Hill other than the guys in that deal. So do you think I could afford to lose Jeter do get Nathan. Thanks for the input.
I like the Rios side of that deal a lot better.
-Rios is an emerging star compared to Magglio, who has almost no chance of matching his numbers from last year.
-Renteria is much more valuable in fantasy than Jeter, especially if the Tigers continue to pick it up.
-Nathan is a huge upgrade over Gagne.
-I'd take Vasquez over Myers, but the offensive side and the huge closer upgrade swing the deal for me.