• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • ChrisC ChrisC Mar 30, 2008 9:59 PM Flag

    Do i do this trade?

    I was wondering if i should do this trade.

    first off i have a very powerful lineup with

    adam dunn
    carlos beltran
    albert pujols
    bobby abreu
    brandon phillips
    matt holliday

    and not many good pitchers so is this a good trade for me

    i give:
    eric chavez
    adrian gonzalez
    raul ibanez

    i get:
    justin verlander
    todd jones

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I would say you have to do that deal. Now, I need YOUR help. I dont just need to know who wins, ok? I need to know if this deal is a pretty fair deal or if someone gets ripped off? Team A gets Josh Hamilton and Erik Bedard. Team B gets Michael Cuddyer, Trevor Hoffman, and Brandon Webb. Is this trade pretty fair or lopsided and why? Thanks!

      • 1 Reply to Jason T
      • i personally think its pretty even because bedard did great things on the orioles,just imagine what he can do on a much better team.

        trevor hoffman is pretty good but one of my biggest question marks is the d-backs this season. yes they got to the nl championship but they are still young and idont know how well webb will do

    • def do it

    • i changed is up a bit but just for facts this is my team at the moment

      c : joe mauer
      1b : albert pujols
      2b : brandon phillips
      3b : chipper jones
      ss : michael young
      of : matt holliday
      of : carlos beltran
      of : adam dunn
      util : bobby abreu
      bn : adrian gonzalez
      bn : raul ibanez
      bn : yunel escobar
      bn : eric chavez

      sp : chris young
      sp : roy halladay
      rp : chad billingsley
      rp : brian wilson
      rp : david weathers
      p : javier vazquez
      p : matt cain
      p : adam wainwright
      p : derek lowe
      p : tom gorzelanny
      bn : yovani gallardo

      now for the trade

      i get:
      justin verlander
      todd jones

      i give:
      adam dunn
      eric chavez
      raul ibanez

    • verlander is still under rated.... grab him you can still afford the power.... he will be a top 5 pitcher

    • i say do it...if u can afford those guys and ur in need of pitching then its an obvious choice


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football