Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
I would give
Aramis rameriez, derek lee, Howie kendric, Shane victorino, roy halladay
I have adrian gonzalez to play 1st if i lose lee. for SP i have haren, bonderman, kennedy, hughes,... THis good trade for all?
A-Rod's not going to have the same impact, Bay's not going to be quite as good, and Cano will give you the same high quality numbers as usual. Victorino is going to destroy and Ramirez and Lee are obviously going to be great and i think, especially if you have hughes, that you need a strong starter like Halladay in your rotation. I wouldn't do it.
I would say you're ripping him off, A-rod alone is already worth all 5 of those guys.
Derek Lee - Round 3 at best?
Amaris Ram - Round 3 also?
Roy Halladay - Round 8?
Shane Victorino - Round 9?
Howie Kendrick - Round 10?
- 1 Reply to Tom.
but for the most part, would you say its a good trade?? i might have the edge but im not ripping him off a lot.. when i sent the proposal i said i think its a great trade for both. all of those hitters are solid and healthy and halladay is a great pitcher and he wanted a solid pitcher. bay had an awful year last year.. so thats chancy... but i hope he accepts it. he said he wanted to take a few days but that he wanted lee and rameriez... but that he also didnt think we could trade.. but hopefully thats a good enought offer.