Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
SortNewest |  Oldest |  Most Replied
  • Luck Trade

    Ryan by Ryan . Nov 14, 2012 1:10 PM . Permalink

    My qb was Big Ben so now im trying to get Luck, his starting qb is brees.

    I sent:
    My: Aaron Hernandez, Kenny Britt
    for His: Andrew Luck

    He rejected and sent back:
    His: Andrew Luck
    for My: Randall Cobb

    My team:
    Carson Palmer
    Big Ben
    Aj Green
    Percy Harvin
    Arian Foster
    Jamaal Charles
    Randall Cobb
    Owen Daniels
    Steve Smith
    Mikel Leshoure
    Aaron Hernandez
    Kenny Britt
    Michael Bush

    Also its only a 10 team league so the qb pool is deep. Should i accept the trade he sent? send one back? or stick with my team?

    • Re: Re: Re: Luck Trade

      Jason by Jason . Nov 15, 2012 9:42 AM . Permalink

      I would not take that if I was the guy your trying to trade with because I dont see a whol...

      I would not take that if I was the guy your trying to trade with because I dont see a whole lot of difference in Leshoure and Donald Brown fantasy wise. I would actually say Donald Brown has been more consistent. Kenny Britt in a 10 team league is pretty much useless right now. (So yes, I would see if he would accept that trade). But I agree with previous post that Carson has been great this year and should have a monster game this week. I would feel perfectly comfortable rolling with Palmer until Big Ben came back.

    • Re: Re: Re: Luck Trade

      Adam S by Adam S . Nov 15, 2012 8:50 AM . Permalink

      I dont know if he will do that or not. I think it sounds fair, but the giving up of one o...

      I dont know if he will do that or not. I think it sounds fair, but the giving up of one of his other guys might prevent him from pulling the trigger now. I think its a good deal for you if the trade goes through. Like I said, if it doesnt work out, its no big deal, Palmer has been averaging the same, if not then more, pts then Luck each week.

    • Re: Re: Luck Trade

      Ryan by Ryan . Nov 15, 2012 1:05 AM . Permalink

      Thanks. I countered with Mikel Leshoure and Kenny Britt for Andrew Luck and Donald Brown. ...

      Thanks. I countered with Mikel Leshoure and Kenny Britt for Andrew Luck and Donald Brown. Good offer?

    • Re: Luck Trade

      Adam S by Adam S . Nov 14, 2012 1:17 PM . Permalink

      Hard to give up Cobb for the years he has been having. Lcuks been killing it lately but r...

      Hard to give up Cobb for the years he has been having. Lcuks been killing it lately but remember his schedule is the easiest in the NFL, he actually has a couple of really tough games coming up including Houston twice. Honestly... Palmer has played beyond his expectations fantasy wise. If you dont wanna give up Cobb, Id stick with Palmer. But its also a fair deal. It depends on how you feel about Luck, if you think he continues his great season, then pull it. I for one wouldnt do it just cause Ben will be back in a week or two probably and Palmer has been playing very well.w