• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Gibbs Gibbs Aug 30, 2012 4:05 PM Flag

    Roddy, Marshall, or Harvin?

    Return Yards @ 30 yards per point; 2 points at 100 yards; 3 points at 200 yards; 4 points at 250 yards
    Receiving Yards @ 10 yards per point; 2 points at 100 yards; 3 points at 150 yards; 4 points at 250 yards
    .5 PPR

    Yahoo says yearly projections are:
    Harvin 239.58
    Roddy 214.09
    Marshall 202.78
    I have Roddy now, but can make a trade for either Marshall or Harvin. It's also a keeper league, so one of these would be a potential keeper next year.

    Which one and why?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Yeah..Harvin is the guy I'm shooting for. Anyone else got any suggestions?

    • Go with Harvin, he'll also get some carries as they will try to limit AP. So between rushing yards, return yards, PPR, and he could be a decent keeper depending on how many you keep

    • I would probably want Marshall.

      Yes Percy Harvin seems good for a keeper league.

      However, the NFL has changed to a passing game so there is still going to be a ton of good WRs.

    • If this is a Keeper, I'd do Harvin.
      1) Harvin is younger and has the potential to become better. You know what you have with Roddy, and to some extent Marshall.
      2) Minn may possibly still use him as a kick returner (you'll have to research this more)... If they do use him, that's just extra points.
      3) Harvin will be a PPR machine this year. Not only will he be the legit go-to reciever, but they'll also be creative with him and use him in the slot, slant routes, deep plays, and end-around (rushing yards). When Ponder was entered in the lineup, he was ranked in the top 2 in targets amongst recievers from that point on. Nothing has really changed since, he'll still get the targets.

      Hope this helps, but my order would be Harvin, Marshall, then White.

    • Is Harvin still returning kicks? PPR i'd usually go Roddy, but Harvin is about all there is up in Minnesota. The return yards might give Percy a boost. He' definately the keeper of the three. Other two getting a bit older.

    • Based on your settings, I would go with Percey Harvin. Out of the two, only he has return yards and has, in fact, returned for at least 1 TD per year.


Expert Fantasy Advice