Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
-
TRADE HELP!!! PLEASE!!!!!!
i've literally been sitting at my computer for 30 minutes debating on this trade.. im in an 8 person PPR league, and this kid offered me:
Michael Vick
Michael Turner
Miles Austin
Santana Moss
Pittsburg
for
Josh Freeman
Jamaal Charles
Roddy White
Vernon Davis
Green Bay
should i do it?????????? my backup tight end is jimmy graham btw so i could afford giving away vernon, my backup qb is kolb, my backup rbs are rashard mendenhall, blount, and jones, and my other recievers are fitzgerald, vincent jackson, manningham, and sims-walker.
PLEASE HELP!!!!!!!-
no chance i would do that
-
id say no. id go for josh freemans upside vs vick's weak offensive line. love vick but damn its hard to see him dominate like he did last year. santana moss is gonna be the only target but u got f-in grossman throwing it to him. dez is gonna take catches away from miles this season. mike turner is the one of the best scoring in the redzone but charles is a bigger play rb and a damn good receiver outta the backfield. just my two cents but i wouldnt do it man.
- 1 Reply to lerenyae
-
you make an extremely valid point... hah yeaaaa i guess youre right man
-
i would do it because the chiefs are splitting touches between all the backs and they said that mcluster will be getting more touches this year and less for charles who already didnt have enough thouches this year...
-
I would say no man.... Its hard to get over the urge to trade before the season but you are safer with what you have. Jamal charles for Turner? White for Austin? Moss for Davis? Pitt for Green bay? Look at it that way. It doesnt add up. Stay still man... Good luck. You will be fine.
- 1 Reply to Austin
-
yea man i guess youre right if you think of it like that.. thanks dude
-
I would do it as well. Freeman and Charles both have much tougher schedules and will not repeat what they did last year.
- 1 Reply to neil g
-
im still debating man this is a tough one
-
it helps your team out by accepting the trade and thats all that matters. youd have three elite starting wideouts and turner and mendenhall looks pretty good to me
-
id do it.
-
Others may not agree but I would do it. Charles has a tough schedule. GB for PITT is a wash. You give up White (monster) but you have depth at WR. Vick if he stays healthy could be a 2 for 1 with rushing and QB stats.
- 2 Replies to rcv
-
yeaaaa i understand what youre saying. mainly its just boiling down to me not wanting to let go of roddy and freeman. plus, idk why they keep lowering turners rank so much? is somethin goin on with him that idk about??
-
Turner is solid and if Austin can keep his hands on the ball should have a great year.
-