• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • A Yahoo! User Nov 13, 2010 8:39 AM Flag

    Trade Question need help

    I was offered Andre Johnson for either Jamaal Charles or Amhad Bradshaw. My other RB's are Rice, McCoy, Blount, Addai and Tolbert. I can only start 2.
    My WR/TE's are Calvin Johnson, Bowe, Knox, Manningham and Antonio Gates. I can start 3.
    I am leaning towards giving him Charles for AJ. Thoughts?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • No way don't do it. I got both Johnson and Charles...Johnson hasn't been performing like a projected rank 7 all season while fighting thru his injured ankle all season. Yea he's the number one wide out but that attracts double coverage leaving the number 2 wide out open plus Foster on the run game takes away passes from him. Charles has been pretty solid, even with splitting carries with Jones...he's been grossing about 10+ points week in and out. I'd turn down that trade and like the other guy said, Tolbert would be a better trade...although he's ok too even with Mathews back in. Bradshaw got 2 TD's the other week, but I see Jacobs getting more TD's in the past few weeks. Bradshaw gets more carries and gets yardage to make up the points so I wouldn't drop him either...I'd trade if there is no deadline for trades toward the playoffs.

    • the other guy wont take f'ing Mike Tolbert for Andre Johnson, thats just stupid

    • check out the matchups for those 2 RB's for your leagues playoffs, whoever has the worse matchups those weeks, get rid of them...gotta be smart and look ahead

    • belive it or not.. i would rather trade tolbert away than charles.. i have both.. i start charles over tolbert.. i am in PPR league and get points off yards. aswell. charles averages over 6 yards a carry.. factor in his catches.. he gets over 8


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football