I would go with B.Roth....Clevaland (ranked 18 in defense for the year) is giving up 220+ yrds per game and allowed 8 passing TDs. Minnesota, on the other hand (defense ranked 6) gives up about 185 passing yrds per game and has only given up 3 passing TDs. B.Roth is rusty, true, but he and his WRs are hurting for some action! I usually play QBs by analyzing the opponent, but everyone's strategy is different...and this is a special situtation as it's his first game back. Good luck!