Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
Before asking me, please answer my question. And read it in it's entirety please!!!
I put CJ on the block and got 2 very solid offers for him. I'm in a 10-team, 3 keeper league. I need help at WR especially. Let me know what trade makes more sense to you. But please look at my team before rushing to judgment.
GET Roddy White and Arian Foster for Chris Johnson and Malcolm Floyd
GET Andre Johnson, Aaron Rodgers, Johnny Knox for Chris Johnson, Joe Flacco, and Malcolm Floyd
Here is my team:
PLEASE HELP!!!! I'm in a tough spot.
Offer 1...you can;t afford to lose a tier 1 RB (you loose 1 and get 1 right back with offer 1)...what i really like about offer 1 is you get a WR on pace for 125 receptions (God I hope you have a PPR format).
Demayius Thomas has let me down...I have Mike Thomas (JAC) available on Waiver/FA...do I drop D. Thomas and pick up M. Thomas?
Wow, take the 2nd one. Having Rodgers, AJ and Rice every year are nice. I'd do it....See if you can exclude Knox and Floyd. Then definately take it!
Please post on my question "HOW DO I GET MJD, WAYNE, OR TURNER?!?!?!"
wow i like both offers for your team. with offer 1 i think you are actually improving at WR & RB. yes i think Foster has more overall talent than CJ, not just speed, and he's on a team that can actually move the ball down field and get more goal-line looks. and Roddy is 10x more valuable than Floyd.
offer 2 you will have a solid starting 3 WR's in AJ/Marshall/Holmes and possibly Floyd if Holmes doesn't produce. you'd be upgrading QB a ton too with Rodgers over Flacco. i'm not buying into Flacco until Rice is 100% healthy, and Rodgers has like 4 other elite weapons to pass to. i would be worried about your RB situation though, having Rice & Best as your starters is not very comforting, since both are nursing injuries and haven't produced lately. Portis is pretty much fantasy worthless at this point with all his injuries and the Torain has been getting more work and producing more with them. McFadden should be back in a week or two, but it's still not a solid RB core.
all in all i'd take offer 1 since i think you are upgrading both positions.
here's my Q:
would you give McCoy&Charles for MJD if you were Team A?
if not which two RB's from A would you give for MJD?
Team A's RB's
Gore - Addai - Torain - McCoy - Charles
Team B's RB's
MJD - Greene - F. Jones
If i was going to take one, I would take the second one, but I'm pretty low on Cutler and Flacco this year. Keeping Andre, Rodgers, and Rice would get you a top option at each position for next year.
Help me out, my post is Help My Team!, as a CJ owner, tell me what you'd take (preferrably excluding rice)