• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Dr. Joe Dr. Joe Sep 8, 2010 7:12 AM Flag

    Rating teams

    Rating the first 15 teams that I see on this post, no more, no less. In my rating I will provide 3-5 sentences providing what I don't like, what I like, and my suggestions as well as a number rating out of 10. PLEASE INCLUDE LEAGUE SIZE OR I WILL NOT REPLY

    Have fun

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • qb- tony romo
      rb- steven jackson
      rb- lesean mccoy
      wr/rb- santana moss
      wr- desean jackson
      wr- brandon marshall
      te- kellen winslow
      d/st- vikings, (titans for week 1)
      k- rob bironas
      bench-felix jones, jahvid best, braylon edwards, donald brown, darren mcfadden, vince young

    • I really hope you will rate this team and thank you in advance. Its a 12 team standard scoring league.
      Starters QB:Flacco or Eli Manning
      RB:Gore
      RB:Greene
      WR:Colston
      WR:Floyd
      Flex:Charles
      TE:Witten
      K:Bironas
      DEF:Dallas
      Bench: Driver, Housh, Royal, Slaton

    • Please rate this team that was drafted and put together in a 12 team league.

      Here is team:

      Trends Passing Rushing Receiving Ret Misc Fum
      Pos Edit Offense Edit Opp Status % Start Yds TD Int Yds TD Yds TD TD 2PT Lost Fan Pts
      QB Tony Romo
      (Dal - QB) QBBN @Was Sun
      5:20 pm 93% - - - - - - - - - -
      WR Miles Austin
      (Dal - WR) WRW/RBN @Was Sun
      5:20 pm 97% - - - - - - - - - -
      WR Chad Ochocinco
      (Cin - WR) WRW/RBN @NE Sun
      10:00 am 91% - - - - - - - - - -
      WR Braylon Edwards
      (NYJ - WR) WRW/RBN Bal Mon
      4:00 pm 25% - - - - - - - - - -
      RB Chris Johnson
      (Ten - RB) RBW/RBN Oak Sun
      10:00 am 97% - - - - - - - - - -
      RB Joseph Addai
      (Ind - RB) RBW/RBN @Hou Sun
      10:00 am 70% - - - - - - - - - -
      TE Brent Celek
      (Phi - TE) TEBN GB Sun
      1:15 pm 83% - - - - - - - - - -
      W/R Marion Barber
      (Dal - RB) RBW/RBN @Was Sun
      5:20 pm 33% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN Jerricho Cotchery
      (NYJ - WR) WRW/RBN Bal Mon
      4:00 pm 9% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN Vince Young
      (Ten - QB) QBBN Oak Sun
      10:00 am 8% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN Kevin Smith
      (Det - RB) RBW/RBN @Chi Sun
      10:00 am 1% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN Deion Branch
      (Sea - WR) WRW/RBN SF Sun
      1:15 pm 1% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN Jeremy Shockey
      (NO - TE) TEBN Min Thu
      5:30 pm 10% - - - - - - - - - -
      BN --empty--

      Trends Field Goals Made PAT
      Pos Edit Kickers Edit Opp Status % Start 0-19 20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ Made Fan Pts
      K Lawrence Tynes
      (NYG - K) KBN Car Sun
      10:00 am 66% - - - - - -
      BN --empty--

      Trends Tackles Turnovers TD Misc
      Pos Edit Defense/Special Teams Edit Opp Status % Start Pts Allow Sack Safe Int Fum
      Rec TD Blk
      Kick Fan Pts
      DEF New York
      (NYG - DEF) DEFBN Car Sun
      10:00 am 50% - - - - - - -


      I had a connection problem so the auto drafter picked me a 5th RB, which I swapped out for shockey

      And I drafted sidney rice, and the reason why I drafted him was I didnt know that he was injured(yeah yeah I know I should have done my more research,but yahoo,draft central,ESPN,etc should have let me know earlier that he was injured)

      So I dropped sidney and added Dion Branch,because Branch has had 1 or 2 good seasons in the past, and now that TJ is gone, branch is the goto WR in the hawks offense.

      The main 2 weaknesses I see with team is 1.braylon edwards is a 4th tier WR not a 3rd tier, so lack of a 3rd WR, and as Dallas goes I go.

      These 2 weaknesses came about because since I pick back to back picks, and since other teams made runs, I just picked the best guys available within the drafting plan I had, which was to go Chris,then a top WR like Austin Miles, then a 2nd RB if top QB's gone, or a top QB 3rd. then a RB 4th then 2nd WR 5th Then a 3rd RB 6th then grab a TE 7th then grab 3rd WR 8th.

      That made it that I just happened to end up with 3 dallas guys on my team. After I took my 2nd WR, The league made a run at WR's and I made a error in taking sidney rice in round 9 or so.

      So I think this is a pretty good team and I think I sould finish in the top 4 teams in my league.

      But what do you guys think??

      thanks for the help

      and good luck during the season

    • This team is for a 12 team league

      QB- Cutler
      RB- Chris Johnson, Jamaal Charles
      WR- Marshall, Nicks
      TE- Celek
      W/R/T- Foster, Arian
      K- Scobee
      DEF- Giants

      BENCH- WR Meachem, Breaston, Mike Williams- Sea; RB- Maroney; WR/RB- McCluster; QB- V. Young;

    • Why are people listening to a guy who is terrible at fantasy sports?

    • 12 team leagues, standard scoring

      1st draft ever

      qb-brees
      wr-ochocinco
      wr-drvier
      wr-santana moss
      rb-sjax
      rb-pierre thomas
      te-cooley
      k-crosby
      def-philly
      bench-jstew
      bench-forte
      bench-jacobs
      bench-orton
      bench-naane

      2dn draft ever-12 team standard scoring

      qb-flacco
      wr-jennings
      wr-steve smith(carolina)
      wr-malcom floyd
      rb-gore
      rb-sjax
      te-whitten
      k-crosby
      def-dallas
      bench-pierre thomas
      bench-jerome harrison
      bench-roethlesberger
      bench-gaffney
      bench- mike williams sea

    • Other leagues- I was thinking of picking up Rob Gronkowski, the TE from New England. Should I drop Huggins for him? Which league? Cause even if Cadillac goes down, will he really be that good on the Bucs offense?

      2nd league-

      12- team 1/2 ppr H2H league. 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 W/T, 1 K, 1 DEF

      QB- Flacco
      WR- Randy Moss, Miles Austin
      RB- Wells, Spiller
      TE- Dallas Clark
      W/T- Berrian
      K- Akers
      DEF- Cincinnati

      Bench- Ricky Williams, Meachem, Donald Brown, Henne,Sidney Rice, Huggins

      3rd league-
      12-team 1/2 ppr H2H league. 1 QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 W/R, 1 W/R/T, 1 K, 1 DEF

      QB- Peyton Manning
      WR- Andre Johnsnon, WR- Steve Smith (NYG)
      RB- Best, Spiller
      TE- Witten
      W/R- Ricky Williams
      W/R/T- Harrison
      K- Rackers
      DEF- New Orleans

      Bench- Hightower, Donald Brown, Mike Williams (TB), Gaffney, Huggins

      • 1 Reply to Double D
      • Team 1: Nice Job, though Wells will split a lot of carries. 2 top tier WRs in 12 teams is hard, though look to trade Austin away soon for a good RB and solid WR in return. Maybe like Austin and Wells for Grant/Mendenhall and Bowe, something along those lines. 8/10

        Team 2: Even better job. WRs are nearly as good, with Best as a better RB. I also think you have decent flex plays. 8.5/10

        Do not drop Huggins for Gonkowski, you have two solid TEs

    • 12-team H2H 0.5 ppr league. 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 W/R, 1 K, 1 DEF

      QB- Flacco, Rothlisberger

      WR- Andre Johnson, Miles Austin, Steve Smith (Giants), Jacoby Jones, Sidney Rice

      RB- Best, Portis, Harrison, Tomlinson, Huggins

      TE- Jermichael Finley, Greg Olsen

      K- Rackers

      DEF- New Orleans

      Idealistic outlook- Stick with what I have and, WR trio destroys, offsets RB concerns

      Flacco becomes a top QB, my 3 main WR's kill it, Best becomes an every week starter, and any one of Harrison, Portis, or Tomlinson rotate into the RB2 spot. Flex is used by Sidney Rice when he comes back, or Harrison/LT if they both get TD's

      Cautionary outlook- My RB's behind Best are all old and full of question marks

      Andre Johnson is awesome and I might value Steve Smith (NYG) more than my opponent, so that makes Miles Austin the trade chip. I'm very high on him too, but he'd be my only viable trade chip to get another dependable RB1 in return. My team would be a little more balanced and have much more security at RB.

      Are any of these trades good for my team and acceptable for the other side?

      Teams with good RB's that need receiver help-



      Team A (already has Mendenhall at RB1)

      I give Flacco, Miles Austin, Portis, Huggins

      I get Shaub, Mattews, Dez Bryant, Sproles




      Team B (Chris Johnson, Ryan Grant, Pierre Thomas at RB, Ochocinco, Harvin, Knox at WR)

      I give Miles Austin, Portis, Greg Olsen, New Orleans D/ST

      I get Ryan Grant, Ochocinco, Zach Miller,San Francisco D/ST

      Or Harrison, Portis, Olsen, New Orleans for Grant, Zach Miller, San Francisco?



      Team C


      I give Miles Austin, Portis, Harrison, Huggins

      I get Turner, Boldin, Foster, Mike Williams

      or maybe just Austin,Portis,Harrison for Turner,Boldin ?

      • 1 Reply to Double D
      • Team C trade would be the best if you could pull that off. Your team is pretty good, I like Flacco and you have very very good WRs. Personally, I think Best posts top 12 stats making him a low end RB1 in 12 teamers. Also, I think Portis will have a bounce back year with 1000 yards rushing and 8 TDs or more. If anything, try to package Smith and Portis for a RB like Pierre Thomas if you could or maybe Benson. Jacoby Jones as a fine WR3 till Sid comes back. 8.5/10

    • 10 Team

      QB: Flacco
      RB1: Micheal Turner
      RB2: Forte
      WR1: Randy Moss
      WR2: Greg Jennings
      Flex: C.J. Spiller
      TE: Jermicheal Finley
      K: Rob Baronis
      Def: Dallas

      Bench:
      Marion Barber
      Jeremy Maclin
      Santonio Holmes
      Big Ben
      Mike Sim-Walker
      Jay Cutler

      12 Team

      QB: Tom Brady
      RB1: Ray Rice
      RB2: Ryan Grant
      WR1: Ochocinco
      WR2: Wes Welker
      WR3: Santana Moss
      Flex: Fred Taylor
      TE: Jermicheal Fineley
      K: Kaeding
      Def: Ravens

      Bench:
      Laurence Maroney
      Fred Jackson
      Kevin Walters
      Donovan McNabb
      Dez Bryant

      • 1 Reply to MarkB
      • Team 1, pretty solid all around, like Spiller as a flex play for week 1, though Fred Jackson might be back. Very thin at RB, however. 8.25/10

        Team 2, Great RBs, Lack of good WRs. Welker is not 100 percent and I hate Ochocinco this year. Fred Taylor is not a good flex play though. See if you can pick up a Gaffney or Mike Williams from FAs. There is a Miles Austin every year, find him first. 8/10

    • View More Messages
 

Expert Fantasy Advice