1. Ray Rice(kind of a no brainer). 2. Randy Moss (I love the TD's every year) 3. Calvin Johnson (Health concern, huge longterm upside) 3. Steven Jackson(huge talent, crappy team, lack of Tds, consistent though).
Those are my thoughts on each player, all have upside/downside. Not sure who to keep. I have the 10th pick in a 12 team draft, standard scoring league and roster.