• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Craig H Craig H Sep 2, 2009 7:23 AM Flag

    Trade Advice needed

    Looking trade away Roddy White to shore up my RB's a little - would either of these deals sound reasonable given the two teams involved?

    Here's my lineup (10 team league - standard scoring):

    QB: Donovan McNabb (BN: Carson Palmer)
    RB1: Steven Jackson
    RB2: Darren McFadden (BN: Larry Johnson, Ray Rice, Knowshon Moreno)
    WR1: Andre Johnson
    WR2: Greg Jennings
    WR3: Roddy White (BN: Anthony Gonzalez, Earl Bennett)
    TE: Dustin Keller
    K: John Kasay
    DST: Chargers

    * Deal A would be:

    Roddy White/Larry Johnson for Ronnie Brown/TJ Houshmanzadeh

    Team A is:

    QB: Jay Cutler (BN: Kyle Orton)
    RB1: Brandon Jacobs
    RB2: Ronnie Brown (BN: Reggie Bush)
    WR1: Randy Moss
    WR2: TJ Houshmanzadeh
    WR3: Donnie Avery (BN: Donald Driver, Michael Crabtree)
    TE: Tony Scheffler
    K: Stephen Gostkowski
    DST: Eagles (BN: Dolphins)

    * Deal B would be:

    Roddy White/Larry Johnson for Ryan Grant/Vincent Jackson.

    Team B is:

    QB: Drew Brees (BN: Jake Delhomme)
    RB1: LaDanian Tomlinson
    RB2: Ryan Grant (BN: Lendale White!)
    WR1: Antonio Bryant
    WR2: Vincent Jackson
    WR3: Lee Evans (BN: Lavernaeus Coles, Dominik Hixon)
    TE: Dallas Clark (BN: John Carlson)
    K: Kris Brown
    DST: Titans (BN: Panthers)

    --- I'm willing to kick in Ray Rice or Knowshon Moreno in either deal if needs be

    --- I'd also be willing to swap Palmer for Cutler in deal A if needs be.

    Would either one of these deals make sense and work for both sides?

    I like McFadden as my first bench RB but I'm not comfortable with his as my starter and he has the same bye week as SJax?

    I'd be happy to lose Roddy as long as I get a reasonable WR3 candidate back in return.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football