• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Popo Popo Oct 7, 2008 8:45 AM Flag

    How does this sound?

    Have a guy offering me nothing (B Edwards) trying to get Forte. This is the second time he's offered that. and it was a counter to my Roayal for Edwards offer (pre-ankle)

    So I countered him Royal andForte for Peterson and Edwards.

    Is that reasonable?

    I think it's reasonable.

    He won't go for it.

    But at least its a reasonable offer no?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • i doubt he'll accept. AP's a monster, and he'll be a lot more consistent than Forte. much more established, which means his owner will be that less likely to trade down.

      and unless the other manager is an idiot, he should know that you can't give up on Edwards yet. Players / teams get off to rough starts, just as players like Royal get off to fantastic starts. i still wouldn't value Royal any higher than Edwards. although, i probably wouldn't value him less either.

      he'd be swapping WR while trading substantially down at RB. won't be accepted.

      • 1 Reply to Clay M
      • Yeah well what I was thinking was he was offering me a joke so I'll counter with Forte producing more currently than AP (albeit mindor) with AP havign a much larger upside and Forte's freshman slump coming on strong.

        And my theory is that Dwards could (should) take off while Royal is already producing.

        I ahve no love for Royal he just rots on my bench. I haveno faith in him.

        What about Forte and Lee Evans for Edwards and Peterson?

        Sound any better.

        My wr's are Evans, Bowe, Royal, Marques Colston and Andre Johnson.

        RB's Forte and Steven jackson,- Sproles, Norwood and Ricky "puff puff give" Williams

        I need A Tight End!

        Eli is my QB

    • I wouldn't accept that trade if you offered it to me.

    • Sounds good to me but I'm biased!

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football