Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
I need your HONEST opinion, as your comments will be shown to both parties of this trade. IS THIS A FAIR TRADE?
Team Blue gets:
KC-RB Larry Johnson
KC-WR Dwayne Bowe
Team Pink gets:
ARI-RB Edgerrin James
TB-WR Joey Galloway
SEA-WR Nate Burleson
Interesting topic here about trade "fairness" - hopefully we got thru to Snowball.....
A friend of mine made a ridiculous offer but it was accepted...clearly the other manager is an idiot (in my opinion) or sees something in the players he/she is getting.
My friend got: Barber, Welker, Witten, A. Rodgers, JAC DEF
He traded away: A. Gonzales, Sidney Rice, Kolby Smith, M. Morris, Andre Hall and Todd Heap
Now I think he got three studs for a bunch of bench garbage...but the other manager said yes.....
Soooo, is it "fair" do you veto? snowball, what would you do with that trade?
- 1 Reply to Kyle
Let's see... A 1st, 4th and 5th round picks being trade for a 5th, 11th and 15th round picks.
Seems like a no-brainer unfair trade. When ever a 1st or 2nd rounder gets traded it raises eyebrows. But now I know better that it is just a stupid trade, and I should allow more of these to occur and let the players play.
Did I do good?
A feel that remark, and must wear it somewhat. I did over argue the point. Even changed the point from an unfair trade to a suspected collusion event. I have acquiessed from it being an unfair trade, thanks to you and the others expressing their opinions. So, thanks to all, you did get through to me.
Well, well. Thanks for all the lively dialogue. I was looking for a veto, but I'm not seeing it from you guys, at least not based on the trade value differential. Proving collusion is a hard thing to do, it just seems like the guy's either colluding or screwing his live-in girlfriend out of players. Either way, not a nice guy.
I agree. he is trying to justify a veto that shouldn't be veto.he just had 10 people tell him the trade is O.K and he is still arguing.I think this might be the same person who picked romo with the 5th pick
"Thanks for those replies. Given that the Pink Team is a newbie (female, if you must know), should the commissioner void this trade for preying on the weak? It is a family (teens and adults) league."
Are you schizo? Those two stories don't match.
Pay $15 to www.sportsjudge.com if you really want. You seem to be looking for justification to veto. I don't see it.
- View More Messages
Expert Fantasy Advice
Nelson Cruz at Colorado sounds automatic, but we're also bringing one of his slumping teammates. … More »
Talking up Jake Arrieta as a top-10 pitcher, trade deadline deals and a look around the league. … More »
Running back theory has shifted significantly in recent years. Will you pick an early back in 2015? … More »
Everyone's in play Sunday, so let's see what's going on for DFS. … More »