I offered LaMont and Cotchery for S.Smith. The guy has Ward and Pittman starting so he needs RB help. His WR isn't the greatest but definitely stronger than RB. He landed some of the top WR free agents. I need a big time WR and S.Smith would be one, but with Carr at the helm things look bad. That's the main reason why I think this is a fair offer. I'm offering a top 10 back(although slipping in value a bit) and a productive receiver for a top 5 potential WR that is injury prone and also losing value. McGahee and Parker should carry me in RB.
If i had spots in my starting roster for both of them. That i wouldnt have them on the bench, I would take that trade. Smith could pan out or bust. I traded Manning , had brees, for Smith and Colston last year and colston got hurt and smith petered out, and I went from first to forth and lost playoffs in first round. Now I'm skeptical of smith.