Roto Arcade - Fantasy

Sun Jul 20, 2008 10:40 pm EDT

Closing Time: The myth of the buy-low

To truly be useful as a writer in the fantasy world, one needs to somewhat-accurately project the future and take a few chances along the way. But too often in this industry, writers play it safe, state the obvious, wait for value changes to develop before they give advice, and ultimately hand you a playbook that only works if you're up against mediocre competition. I'm not going to say I've never fallen into that trap myself (I welcome your respectful and intelligent feedback on anything), but the goal is to keep looking forward, constantly search for news you can use and apply.

I heard Justin Verlander discussed as a buy-low in some fantasy circles around the All-Star break, and that gets my dander up. The guy had 12 useful turns in a row entering the break - he had been effective since mid-May for crying out loud. How could his fantasy owners not realize this? Verlander added to the streak with another solid turn at Baltimore Sunday, so let's just all agree that Verlander is legit and move on.

Alex Rios has been running all month (eight steals), and he added some power to the mix Sunday (homer, two steals). Buy-low, you say? That's great, if Rios is owned by someone who checks boxscores about once a month. Robinson Cano was an excellent buy-low candidate not too long ago, but an 8-for-14 stretch against Oakland this weekend probably kills the opportunity.

Sell-high is another concept that gets fudged in our communities. Can you really sell high on a guy like Xavier Nady when he gets hot for a month or two? When a soft-tosser like Jesse Litsch gets a few wins and some luck on balls in play, is it really possible to peddle him to an opponent who thinks he's the next Roy Halladay? Hey, maybe it is, and if so great. But if that's the nature of your competition, you don't need our help. Just repeat until rich.

If I had $20 for every "Cliff Lee won't keep this up" nugget I've passed over this season, I'd be typing this from Hawaii surrounded by hula dancers. Anyone can tell you that Cliff Lee won't maintain an ERA below 2, or Chipper Jones is unlikely to hit .400, or Nate McLouth isn't going to win the National League MVP. The real question on surprising surges is this: "what level can we expect the player in question to settle in at?" 

That Sunday rant out of the way, let's take a stroll through 15 ballparks and see what's worth a mention. I fully realize as I collect these stories that it's impossible to make the column perfectly relatable to everyone- there are so many ways to play Fantasy Baseball these days. Hopefully there's something you can use, or enjoy, in the bullets to follow.

So what's the story with Billy Wagner? He experienced shoulder cramping in the bullpen Sunday, but the Mets still brought him out for a save at Cincinnati, and he passed the test with flying colors (perfect inning, three strikeouts). Nonetheless, the team will play it safe and do an MRI Monday. (Monday update: The Mets are no longer planning that MRI. Alrighty, then.) Sticking with the Metropolitans, Pedro Martinez had a good session on flat ground Sunday and is hoping to return to action next weekend. In a weekly-transaction league, there's no way I risk it with him this period.

Jermaine Dye took a pitch off the knee Sunday and was forced out of the game; X-rays came back negative and he's day-to-day. It's hard to keep a good man down in Chicago, especially when he's wearing No. 23 (MJ, Ryno, the ridiculous Devin Hester, etc).

You probably ignored Willie Harris's big day in Atlanta (homer, five RBIs, three walks), but let's take a deeper look here. The plucky Harris has been a useful fantasy option since the beginning of June (.315, four homers, six steals), and he covers three positions in the Y! game (2B, 3B, OF). I'm not saying you should run out and grab him in shallow mixed leagues, but if you're digging a little deeper, he's a handy bench option and probably free for the taking (Harris was less than 1 percent owned in Yahoo Nation last I checked).

Highly-regarded lefty Jaime Garcia made his first major-league start for the Cardinals Sunday, an ordinary performance (5 IP, 5H, 3 R, 1 BB, 4 K, 2 HR). He was dominant in six starts at Double-A earlier in the year, but his Triple-A results (4.59 ERA, 1.41 ratio) are enough to keep him off the mixed-league radar for the moment, albeit he did have 57 strikeouts in 68.2 innings.

I bought into the Jacoby Ellsbury hype and pursued him pretty aggressively in some mid-season drafts. Alas, for the last few weeks, the joke's on me: he's hitting a punchless .250 since June 1, lefties are eating his lunch, and he has just one steal (in four attempts) in July.

Aaron Miles hit a walk-off grand slam for the Redbirds Sunday, his third hit of the day, and he's now carrying around a robust .323average. He's still a tricky call for fantasy owners, though, because Tony La Russa loves to fill out a different lineup card every day and Miles is never guaranteed to play more than 3-4 times in a week. I've had Miles on my Tout Wars roster (NL-only) for most of the year, and despite the fact that it's NL-only (where the pickings get slim), I'm generally hesitant to start him.

Ryan Zimmerman will come off the disabled list and play Tuesday, but it remains to be seen how healthy his shoulder is. I'm not overly bullish here. I do feel bad for Dmitri Young, who's battling blood-sugar issues and had to go on the DL. 

Not an injury blog: Fausto Carmona (hip) will meet up with the Indians in Anaheim Monday, and if a side session goes well, we might see him on the mound later in the week . . . A sore right ankle kept Adam Jones out of the lineup Sunday . . . Troy Percival (hamstring) came off the DL Sunday and worked a scoreless inning. The Rays figure to give Percival the ninth inning back and spoil all of our Grant Balfour/Dan Wheeler fun, but keep in mind Percy turns 39 in a couple of weeks . . . The Cubs expect to get Alfonso Soriano (hand) back in the mix this week, perhaps as soon as Wednesday . . . J.J. Putz (elbow) came off the DL Sunday, but the Mariners say they won't use him in save chances immediately . . . A forearm injury pushed Jose Contreras to the disabled list. He's been hammered over his last seven turns, so this news shouldn't hurt you . . . As expected, Roy Oswalt and his hip landed on the DL . . . Michael Cuddyer remains in limbo; he'll have a CT scan on his hand Monday . . . Yunel Escobar should be able to play this week, perhaps as soon as Monday

No fantasy happiness with the Ray Durham trade - now Rickie Weeks owners have to worry, and Durham's playing time surely will be less in Milwaukee. The Giants have multiple options at second, so mixed leagers can continue to ignore that Bermuda Triangle for the moment. 

Brandon Lyon fell apart against the Dodgers, perhaps because he was working for the third consecutive day. He's not the easiest guy to hedge against, as the Diamondbacks have a deep but tricky bullpen to diagnose

Speed round: Ryan Sweeney had two more hits, lifting his average to .307. He's not a power guy at all, but if you need average and a little speed (eight steals), he's worth a look as an outfield back-fill . . . The extra-base hit watch for Ichiro Suzuki (136 plate appearances) ended on Saturday, when he took a Masa Kobayashi pitch out of the park in the ninth inning . . . Richie Sexson didn't start for the second straight day, as it looks like the Yanks will wisely keep him as a platoon guy. It kills his fantasy value, but it's the right move . . . Three more hits and a pair of RBIs for Carlos Delgado, who's raking in July (.419/.500/.726). . . Marcus Thames went deep again for the Tigers and now has an amazing 19 homers on just 196 at-bats.

Handshakers: Another save and three pretty strikeouts for Francisco Rodriguez (40), though I stubbornly maintain that the club that opens the vaults for him this winter will regret it . . . Jonathan Broxton labored through his second big-chair opportunity (one run, two baserunners, 23 pitches), but he got the job done in the end and that's all we care about . . . Joakim Soria (26) needed just eight pitches to put the White Sox away, and that was with two strikeouts thrown in. No strikeouts for Mariano Rivera (24), but it was a tidy 11-pitch outing . . . The trick-or-treat season continues for C.J. Wilson (23); he's now converted 15 straight save chances, despite his rocky ERA (4.89) and ratio (1.56).

I'm late for a date (okay, it's a football draft), so let's head to the comments and try to figure this all out.

digg delicious
more

47 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Poseur
    1. Posted by Poseur Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No love for Duchsherer. The A's paltry offense continues to waste his incredibly stellar season. You know Pianow, his era his NOT going to stay under 2.00.
  2. JP
    2. Posted by JP Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i'm curious, did anyone watch manny parra's dominance over the giants? my question is (because i had to watch the game on mlb tv) whether or not corey hart should've been charged with an error, ruining parra's shutout with 2 gone in the 8th. i mean, it looked like he was nonchalant and dropped the ball...have to see a replay of it, but there is no way that there was a hit there...
  3. pianow
    3. Posted by pianow Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was hoping to catch some Parra today, didn't get any pictures. He's very much worth talking about. Please do share your thoughts and angles here.
  4. drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH
    4. Posted by drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Mets/Reds game was another classic. Beltran did his best to screw it up, but even that dunce couldn't hand the game to Cinci.
  5. Fergie
    5. Posted by Fergie Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How about some Salomon love? Torres got a sweet, one batter, save after Shouse blew a 7-2 lead.
    Just when I thought that potent damn Brewer offense would blow a save chance for the anti-Gagne with two useless, stupid, non-sensical, unnecessary, wasteful, insipid, runs in the top of the ninth.
  6. pianow
    6. Posted by pianow Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yep, the Torres handshake slipped by me. I wish I had that guy on some teams; Gagne was No. 1 on my "don't trust" list in March, but owning guys like Riske and Mota got me nowhere.
    Torres's resume didn't inspire a lot of confidence, but if you get the manager endorsement and the cushy "working with a net" saves to convert, it's really not that hard.
  7. Tommy
    7. Posted by Tommy Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I am digging Parra. As a Giants fan, it isn't saying much shutting down their horrible offense, but Parra looked good. He has had some pretty shotty outings (8 walks in one), but keeps winning with the help of the Brewers offense. I plan on riding him out the rest of the year.
  8. Blake H
    8. Posted by Blake H Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Pianow, 6-pack OVER/UNDER: 1) .250 Avg for Adam Dunn. 2) 3.00 ERA for Cliff Lee. 3) 2.75 ERA for Justin Duchscherer. 4) 60 saves for K-Rod. 5) 50 Stls for Reyes. 6) Carlos Zambrano will hit more HR than the whole Pad Squad. Thanks Pianow
  9. JoshuaG
    9. Posted by JoshuaG Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great article Scott. I realize that you're mostly venting, but it is nice to hear someone attempt to shift the focus from stating the obvious to adding value. Kudos.
  10. JP
    10. Posted by JP Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Tommy,
    what's funny about that 8 walks game (and his earlier struggles with walks) I think has more to do with him still finally able to trust his stuff...he was considered, at one point, to have the best control in the minors and the top Brewers pitching prospect (above Yovani...though he was a young 'un at the time). I mean, today, he was dialing up high 90s heat. where a few weeks ago, he was working in the low 90s, which is also notable.
  11. pianow
    11. Posted by pianow Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dunn under .250; Cliff Lee 3.12 ERA; JD definitely over 3.00 as well; K-Rod saves 61*.
    Casey Blake, you better watch your speed.
  12. Adrian Argh
    12. Posted by Adrian Argh Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    nomar love?
  13. spit
    13. Posted by spit Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its refreshing to see someone just as annoyed as I am for what passes for fantasy baseball expertise. Really? I should try to get David Wright for Milton Bradley? Who in the hell would accept trades like that?
  14. jay g
    14. Posted by jay g Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    parra is legit.. big roadbumps for volquez continue.. longoria is the only legit rookie.. cano is on FIRE and will stay on fire the rest of the year.. ANIBAL SANCHEZ WILL DOMINATE!! thoughts?
  15. jay g
    15. Posted by jay g Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    few weeks ago shipped away david wright, yunel escobar, kurt suzuki, and matt capps and got michael young, geovany soto, and K-rod in return, i had longoria riding the pine so he has filled in very nicely at 3rd.. what do you think of that trade?
  16. drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH
    16. Posted by drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Scott did you draft any Stillers tonight? Who on their team do you think will have the best value?
  17. pianow
    17. Posted by pianow Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I wound up with Hines Ward, not really by choice but I needed WR depth. I like Holmes a lot but everyone does. I would take Parker if the price totally bottoms out.
  18. drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH
    18. Posted by drinkCOORSsmokeBUDeatBUSCH Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    what kind of hype is out there about their D? Would you ride with them? Their FS position can't do much worse...
  19. D-Neff
    19. Posted by D-Neff Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Just scanning over the column, as someone who is on the boards alot on here-I haven't figured out why so many people have been suggesting to buy low on Verlander either, apparently half the baseball world has missed out on the fact he got his command back in May. I'm glad you discussed this, now maybe everyone will realize this finally.
  20. theillest2000
    20. Posted by theillest2000 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    bullet point: I traded Ervin "Magic" Santana and "Sarah" Conor Jackson for Verlander a couple months ago. I'm liking the returns I'm gettin right now. I'll always take the sure thing over the up and comers.
    Windy City bullet point: Jermaine "Ryno Jeffrey Hester" Dye will be just fine.
    Leave It Alone bullet point: Keep Willie Harris on the free agent list. Pick him up and he'll produce nothing.
    Jerry Seinfeld bullet point: What's the deal with Jacoby Ellsbury? He was getting about 3 steals per game for a while. I live on the west coast but I still see 3 Red Sox games a week on national broadcasts. I see him on first base in plenty of steal situations, but he doesn't run anymore. I don't get it.
    Random bullet point: Hong-Chih Kuo rocks my socks! He didn't pitch today, but I just wanted to throw that in there.
  21. Travis C
    21. Posted by Travis C Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i traded carlos pena to get verlander! man that worked out so far!!!
  22. AgentUtah
    22. Posted by AgentUtah Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stupid D-backs. Webb and Haren should each have several more wins this season.
    Verlander was absolutely pounding the strike zone. Leyland could have let him face one more hitter before he pulled him. Also, I know it has no fantasy relevance, but Brandon Inge was unreal at third base over this series.
  23. HamNCheese
    23. Posted by HamNCheese Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How bout some love for Scott Baker as well? What are his ownership numbers at? just too bad the Twins got blanked
  24. The Beav
    24. Posted by The Beav Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I got Verlander and Dye for Jenks and Pierre about 2 months ago. I had depth at closer and was fine at steals. Dye was more of a throw in. Great trade for me, not to mention both Pierre and Jenks got hurt shortly after.
  25. The Jaker
    25. Posted by The Jaker Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "Pedro Martinez had a good session on flat ground Sunday and is hoping to return to action next weekend." - Where have I heard that before?
    "I bought into the Jacoby Ellsbury hype and pursued him pretty aggressively in some mid-season drafts. Alas, for the last few weeks, the joke's on me: he's hitting a punchless .250 since June 1, lefties are eating his lunch, and he has just one steal (in four attempts) in July." - Jacoby's slowdown is like the US recession, sure there are numbers to back it up, but it is perception driven. Eventually they are both going to turn around.
    And finally, are you saying Willie Harris is a buy-low candidate?

Roto Arcade

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Andy Behrens

Roto Arcade is a fantasy sports blog edited by Andy Behrens. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Y! Sports Blogs

Roto Arcade Recent Readers