Examining the five penalties with no signal, according to the NHL rulebook

Harrison Mooney

Section 4 of the National Hockey League's official rulebook outlines the different types of penalties that may be called over the course of your standard NHL game -- minors, majors, matches, and everything in between. It's a highly detailed section.

But, for all its detail, it skimps in one particular area. Within that section is Rule 29, which breaks down the various signals for the NHL's different infractions. Appropriately, Rule 29 demonstrates 29 different signals. But what's curious is that there are 34 penalties listed.

That's right. There are five penalties in the NHL rulebook listed with no signal, and looking at it, there's just no reason these have to be without. Sure, in a few cases, the penalty might call for a slightly more demonstrative approach to officiating, but in this writer's humble opinion, NHL officials could stand to be a little more animated. Maybe they'd remember to turn their microphones on before calling penalties if they had to be a little more dialled in when signalling infractions.

The five signal-less penalties are as follows.

1 | Rule 29.13 - Head-butting

You can understand why the league might not see a need to give this one a signal, since it doesn't happen all that often. But it happens. Just ask Patrick "The Rhino" Kaleta:

What the Hell.

Admittedly, in most cases, a head-butting penalty is self-evident enough that no one is looking to the official afterwards to figure out just why the whistle blew. But still. There's no reason for this to be without a signal. It's easy enough to mimic. Why can't officials just throw their head to one side like Steve and Doug Butabi they make the call? Is it fear of breaking the glass? Do it away from the boards.

2 | Rule 29.21 - Kicking

Just like head-butting, this one seems like a no-brainer. The kicking motion isn't exactly a difficult one to perform. But, just like head-butting, it isn't called all that often, probably because the players wear knives on their feet.

Still, we see them occasionally. Back in 2005, Martin Havlat was suspended five games for kicking Hal Gill in the groin -- yes, that happened.

Another thing that happened as a result was this fun piece of writing from Don Brennan, titled, "Havlat did what he had to do", and subtitled, "Big Bruin was pushing Senator around". In the article, Havlat asks what you would do if Hal Gill was pushing you around. Brennan: "My reply: The same thing."

Sometimes you have to kick Hal Gill in the groin. That in mind, another kicking incident could be just around the corner. The NHL needs to cook up a signal before they're caught unprepared.

3 | Rule 29.23 - Match penalty (NO SIGNAL)

The match penalty, which is effectively just throwing a player out a game, has no signal. Of course, it can be assessed for just about anything, so unlike head-butting and kicking, there isn't a specific motion to mime. But still. This one isn't rocket science.

Major League baseball effectively has match penalties, and their umpires really get into doling them out. They point a finger at the offending party, then sort of "throw it" out of the stadium. It works. Heck, here's an umpire throwing out an organist.

Hockey recently adopted Major League Baseball's union head. Now they need to adopt the sport's gesture for giving out match penalties. If it's good enough to toss the kid playing the organ, it's good enough for hockey players.

4 | Rule 29.29 - Throwing equipment (NO SIGNAL)

Here's a scenario I suspect we'll one day see: a defender breaks his stick, and is rushing back to turn a potential odd-man rush into an even-man rush. On his way past the bench, one of his teammates hands him a stick... but he botches the handoff.

You don't see a lot of botched handoffs in the NHL, but here's the thing to consider: it's against the rules to throw a stick onto the ice to a player who has lost or broken his. Hence, if during that handoff, the player misses it and the stick falls to the ice, that player could be penalized.

But there's no signal for it. The piece of equipment lying on the ice may speak for itself, in a sense, but I can't understand for the life of me why NHL officials don't have an overhand throwing motion in this case. They already have an underhand motion for the hand pass.

5 | Rule 29.31 - Too many men on the ice

And finally, there is no signal for too many men on the ice, and frankly, there needs to be. How often does the whistle blow for this call, only to have everyone looking around wondering what the deal is?

That wouldn't happen if there was a signal.

Part of me suspects that this infraction is without one simply because the league has yet to come up with one. But it's not that hard. Have the official show six fingers. Simple as that.

  • Why Joey Bosa better hope the Chargers' offer still stands

    On Wednesday, Shutdown Corner’s Frank Schwab did a great job of updating the Joey Bosa situation — namely how the San Diego Chargers made this standoff public and ugly. Oh, sure, these are the Chargers we’re talking about, and calling them a well-run organization might not be able to be done with a straight face. Perhaps the Chargers, coming off a 4-12 nightmare of a season, could have found better ways to get this thing done — especially in an era where the draft-pick holdout has gone the way of the Edsel.

    Shutdown Corner
  • Hope Solo’s ban from USWNT about much more than “coward” comments

    On Wednesday the news broke that U.S. Soccer had banned Hope Solo for six months from the USWNT and had terminated her contract as a member of the national team. In truth, we all saw this coming. The official reason given by Sunil Gulati, president of U.S. Soccer, was that Solo’s comments following the USA’s shock defeat on penalty kicks to Sweden in the quarterfinals at Rio 2016 were “unacceptable and do not meet the standard of conduct we require from our National Team players.” Solo, 35, said that Sweden played like “a bunch of cowards” and argued that “the best team did not win.” Were the comments out of line? Yes. Were they in the heat of the moment? Yes. Were they worthy of a six-month

    ProSoccerTalk
  • Lane Johnson says he'll sue supplement company over suspension

    Philadelphia Eagles offensive tackle Lane Johnson first complained about the NFLPA’s lack of supplement testing after his positive test triggered a 10-game suspension. Now he says he’ll sue the supplement company that he says sold him the amino acids that led to the positive test. Johnson had $25 million in guaranteed money remaining on his deal, but the positive test meant none of that money is guaranteed anymore due to a clause in his contract.

    Shutdown Corner
  • British Olympic Team Has Luggage Mishap

    The country's Olympic athletes returned home from Rio but were stuck at baggage claim because each had the same red, Team GB bag. If they all came to returning than on the same flags of I can't see this team great Britain's Twitter account baggage collection could be interesting hash tag same same hash tag great to be back.

    ABC News Videos
  • Texas sends note to Arizona after death of Zach Hemmila (Photo)

    After Arizona lineman Zach Hemmila died earlier this month, the Texas football program reached out to the Wildcats to offer support. Wildcats tight end Josh Kern shared a photo of a handwritten letter and notes from the Longhorns. Arizona spokesman Blair Willis told the Austin American-Statesman that Texas is one of 50 football programs across the country (from high school to the NFL) to send a card to the Wildcats to offer condolences.

    Dr. Saturday
  • Geno Smith publicly named Fitzpatrick's backup

    Geno Smith is still No. 2 for the New York Jets. After previously being vague about the situation a few days ago, coach Todd Bowles said Smith will play after starter Ryan Fitzpatrick in the preseason game against the Giants on Saturday night. "You always prepare the same way," Smith said after practice Wednesday. "It's really no different. I'm just continuing to work hard." There had been some uncertainty about the pecking order of the backups after Bryce Petty had a good performance and Smith struggled against Washington. On Sunday, Bowles wouldn't say for sure what the rotation of the quarterbacks would be this week. He did say then that he was clear about the four quarterbacks on the roster,

    SNY
  • Mexican League pitcher flips off batter before striking him out

    Over the past few seasons, a debate has raged within baseball over how much players should be allowed to celebrate big moments. One side believes an excessive bat flip or fist pump warrants a 98 mph fastball to the ribs. The other side thinks big moment

    Big League Stew
  • NASCAR announces warnings to Xfinity teams

    In the span of less than a week, the long-term sponsor outlook of JR Motorsports dramatically has shifted from potentially bleak to firmly bright. On the heels of NASCAR phenom William Byron being added to the Xfinity Series team for the 2017 season (as part of a multiyear deal with Hendrick Motorsports), JRM announced Wednesday that sponsor OneMain has reversed course and decided to remain on Elliott Sadler’s No. 1 Chevrolet. “When we found out this was going to happen, my wife and I just cried that whole morning tears of joy knowing there’s so much stability,” Sadler, 41, told NBC Sports. OneMain, which initially had informed JRM nearly two months ago of its plan to leave NASCAR, will sponsor Sadler for 20 races in each of the next two seasons, JRM general manager Kelley Earnhardt Miller said.

    NASCAR Talk
  • Los Angeles celebrates 'Kobe Bryant Day'

    It’s been a whirlwind retirement for Kobe Bryant. On Monday, the Los Angeles Lakers legend rang the opening bell at the New York Stock Exchange to unveil his new $100 million venture-capital fund. The date marks the two jersey numbers (8 and 24) Bryant wore during his 20 years with the club.

    Ball Don't Lie
  • Georges St-Pierre Will Reportedly Make His Long-Anticipated Return To MMA At UFC 206

    Following the news that former welterweight kingpin Georges St-Pierre had “started the USADA process” to mount a UFC comeback after three years away from the game, it appears that “Rush” has actually, finally set a date for his official return. Big Brand Boys is reporting (citing “inside sources”) that GSP has been locked in to return at UFC 206 on December 10, 2016 in, where else, Toronto. St-Pierre’s opponent has not been named as of yet, but it’s being suggested that he was “offered a superfight” in Toronto with names like Nick Diaz and even middleweight champion Michael Bisping finding their way to the top of the rumor mill. While a fight with either of those two would likely draw the most eyeballs, it would directly conflict with what welterweight champ Tyron Woodley told Sirius XM’s Jason Ellis just a few weeks ago.

    UPROXX
  • Best Player in Europe: Cristiano Ronaldo beats Bale, Griezmann to win award

    Cristiano Ronaldo was named the Best Player in Europe by UEFA on Thursday in Monaco, following the group stage draw for the UEFA Champions League. Ronaldo, 31, beat other finalists teammate and Welsh international Gareth Bale and France and Atletico Madrid striker Antoine Griezmann to the award for the 2015-16 season. Barcelona duo Lionel Messi came fourth and Luis Suarez finished in fifth. The Portuguese striker scored 51 goals in 48 games for Real Madrid last season and led Portugal to its first-ever major title as a nation, winning the EURO 2016 trophy. Ronaldo said on stage that he was “living his dream” by playing football as he won the award for a second time in his career, the list title

    ProSoccerTalk
  • Puck Daddy Summer Series: Weird San Jose Sharks

    What Puck Daddy’s 2016 Summer Series seeks to do is capture those indefinable, quirky, oddities that occur every season. SJ Sharkie, team mascot extraordinaire, decided that he wanted to outdo fellow Californian Wild Wing’s “I’ll set myself on fire” disaster back in 1995, committed to his usual pre-game entrance of dropping down from the rafters a la WCW’s Sting. Sharkie started his routine, girded his loins, and began his descent.

    Puck Daddy
  • National TV talk show blasts Eagles for trading up to draft Carson Wentz

    Carson Wentz came to Eagles with a lot of fanfare and expectations. Fans have taken to Wentz already as shown by how many No.11 jerseys are on the backs of people walking around Philadelphia. The Eagles got the No.2 pick (Carson Wentz) and a 2017 4th-round pick in exchange for No.8 pick (Jack Conklin), a 3rd-round pick (Daryl Worley) a 4th-round pick (Connor Cook) along with a 2017 first round pick and a 2018 2nd-round pick. Max Kellerman is a newcomer to the ESPN show, “First Take.” He voiced his displeasure towards the Eagles trade when he was on the show with Stephen A. Smith and Damien Woody. “Obviously, at the time they made the trade, they made a mistake,” Kellerman said. “They gave up

    Eagles Wire
  • The Patriots traded center Bryan Stork to the Redskins, but he could retire

    First, it was reported that the New England Patriots were planning on releasing their third-year center, who started in their Super Bowl XLIX win as a rookie in the 2014 season. Then word arose that the Washington Redskins, seeking an upgrade, had sent a conditional draft pick to the Patriots for Stork. Then came another odd turn: Was the concussion-plagued Stork, 25, considering retiring instead of joining his new team?

    Shutdown Corner
  • The real history of Native American team names

    WASHINGTON — Native American team names mean honor and respect. That’s what executives of pro sports clubs often say. History tells a different story. Kevin Gover punctuates this point with a rueful smile. He is director of the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of the American Indian and a citizen of the Pawnee Tribe of Oklahoma. The Capitol dome looms outside the windows of his fifth-floor office as he talks about the historical context of an era when Native American mascots proliferated like wildflowers. Baseball’s Boston Braves adopted their team name in 1912. The Cleveland Indians took theirs in 1915. Scores of high schools and colleges across the country assumed these and other Indian

    USA Today
  • Look how far Billy Hamilton ran to make this amazing catch

    Somebody give Billy Hamilton a gold medal. Sure, the Olympics are over, but holy moly, the catch the Cincinnati Reds centerfielder made Tuesday night against the Texas Rangers is worth a medal and a trip to the top of a podium. Carlos Beltran hit a ball to left-center that seemed like a sure-thing gapper off the bat.

    Big League Stew
  • Rory McIlroy Not Switching Equipment Yet Despite New Putter in Bag

    Rory McIlroy may have a Scotty Cameron putter in the bag this week at The Barclays, but he's not making any major equipment moves yet. Following Nike's announcement that the athletic giant is getting out of the equipment game, McIlroy confirmed Wednesday that he's switched out his Nike Method Origin putter for a Scotty Cameron M1 prototype.

    Golf
  • David Robinson cautions that Durant and Warriors have short title window

    David Robinson and Steve Kerr celebrate the re-opening of a championship window. Despite the recent break provided by the Olympics, the bulk of this NBA offseason has been occupied by discussion and emotion regarding Kevin Durant’s move to the Golden State Warriors. Like LeBron James before him, Durant has helped create a new overwhelming title favorite.

    Ball Don't Lie
  • Yoenis Cespedes says he won't opt out of Mets contract

    The New York Mets somehow finding a way to bring back outfielder Yoenis Cespedes this past winter was one of the biggest stories of the offseason. After singlehandedly taking the Mets to the playoffs with a spectacular second half, it was assumed Cespedes’ price range on the market would exceed what the Mets were willing to pay. In order to bring back Cespedes, the Mets needed to get creative with their deal.

    Big League Stew
  • Transfer needs for Premier League teams

    We are one week away from the transfer window slamming shut on Premier League clubs, some of whom have a lot of glaring holes. Others? Not-so-much, but all 20 teams certainly have areas their managers would love to see strengthened for the other 36 games of this grueling season. It’s hard for some teams to assess at this point, with players coming off busy summers, and adapting to new leagues, coaches and roles. Some teams, like Hull City, are off to a dream start but surely also no illusions. Others, like Arsenal, know things aren’t nearly as bad as they seem after a 1-point start to the campaign. Although things are indeed bad. Just not relegation bad. Let’s wait no more… Arsenal — I’m starting

    ProSoccerTalk
  • Jared Bednar brings championship resume as new Avalanche head coach

    Two weeks after Patrick Roy abruptly resigned, the Colorado Avalanche have found their next head coach. After spending the last two seasons as a head coach in the AHL, Jared Bednar will get his shot at the NHL as he will be the one to replace Roy behind the Avalanche bench. “After profiling the type of coach I wanted for our team and going through an interview process with several good candidates, I believe that Jared Bednar is the best person to lead this team behind the bench,” said Avalanche EVP and GM Joe Sakic in a statement.

    Puck Daddy
  • Bouwmeester named to Canada’s World Cup team, replacing the injured Duncan Keith

    St. Louis Blues veteran defenseman Jay Bouwmeester has been named to Canada’s 23-man roster for the upcoming World Cup of Hockey. He will replace Chicago Blackhawks blue liner Duncan Keith, who is rehabbing a right knee injury. “As Duncan continues offseason rehabilitation on the right knee injury that he sustained last season, we understand his decision not to participate in next month’s World Cup of Hockey,” Blackhawks team physician, Dr. Michael Terry, said in a statement. “We believe it is in his best interests to focus on getting stronger and not risk further injury.” Bouwmeester, a left-handed shot just as Keith is, joins his Blues teammate Alex Pietrangelo on the Canadian roster. The two

    ProHockeyTalk
  • Tom Coughlin, John Mara together on NFL's competition committee? It appears so

    Tom Coughlin’s resignation from the New York Giants was an awkward affair. According to ESPN’s Adam Schefter, the out-of-work Coughlin joins two other prominent newcomers to the influential committee. Along with John Elway and Bruce Arians, former NYG HC Tom Coughlin also has been added to NFL's competition committee, per source.

    Shutdown Corner
  • Drake -- Hits Half-Court Shot ... From His Back!!! (VIDEO)

    Here's Drake taking some time away from destroying Meek Mill's life to display some athletic skill ... hitting a half-court shot WHILE LAYING ON HIS BACK. We're assuming it went down in Atlanta because Drake is on tour there ... and the court clearly says "Atlanta" in the Hawks font (we're detectives) ... but the main point is CHECK OUT THE SHOT. Drake drains it calmly then mugs for the camera while walking away like he just won game 7 of the NBA finals ... and we gotta say it's pretty cool. No word on how many shots he took ... but at least we have video proof no ghost-shooters were involved ... we kid.

    TMZ
  • Yankees startled by unexpected visitor in Safeco Field dugout

    The New York Yankees were going about their business in impressive fashion on Wednesday when an unexpected and unwelcomed visitor dropped into their dugout. Fortunately, the Yankees were in the field at the time of the incident. The Yankees dugout had mostly emptied out in the middle of the eighth inning as the Bombers took the field for the bottom of the frame.

    Big League Stew